15 Times People Broke The Ice On Dating Apps By Being As Weird As Possible

If you've ever been on a dating app, you know it's pretty common to receive some wild and weird messages. So when Reddit user u/WarmSlice1885 asked: "People who use dating apps, what is the weirdest message you've gotten to start a conversation?", so many people have opinions on the matter. Here's what they had to say below.

1."Matched with a woman. Her first message was, 'I guess you’ll do.'"

Person in green sleeves holding phone with dating app profile of Joshua, 31. Phone and a cup of coffee with heart-shaped foam on a wooden table
Oscar Wong / Getty Images

2."A friend got the message: 'Wow, your eyes could start a cult.'"

u/pinkynarftroz

"Not gonna lie, that one might actually work on me."

u/Otaku_in_Red

3."After my girlfriend and I started dating, she showed me her dating profile so I could see how many messages she was getting. It was about 50-70 per day, and most of them were just 'hi.' A few were really creepy: 'You look like my daughter/student/sister.' However, one stood out to us, and we still laugh about it to this day: 'You ever get fucked by a marine baby?' There were no punctuation or question marks, so we asked ourselves, 'What, like a baby shark? Baby whale?' In the end, she had 1,500 unread messages when she deactivated her account."

whale swimming under water
By Wildestanimal / Getty Images

4."The weirdest first message I've received was: 'My hovercraft is full of eels,' and I can't imagine what sort of conversation she expects if the person she sends the message to doesn't happen to be a Monty Python fan (we're getting old and rare here)."

u/malsomnus

5."'Excuse me, good sir, would you kindly like to hook up?' She was clearly wasted. Five minutes later, she unmatches. Apparently, she didn't like that I wasn't available immediately. This isn't a fucking Wendy's."

man looking at a dating app profile on his phone
Catherine Falls Commercial / Getty Images

6."Where's the nearest KFC to you because Friday nights are for chicken 'n dickin.'"

u/crazyforkovu

"Did you get original or extra crispy?"

u/chuckagain

7."I was on Bumble and got asked about my Myers-Briggs personality type. When I responded, she unmatched me immediately. I gotta respect the hustle."

Wooden blocks on a table spell out "Myers-Briggs Type Indicator" as a hand places the final block labeled "I."
Thx4stock / Getty Images

8."A woman once messaged me with something along the lines of 'Do you ever see a bunch of cheese and say damn, I want to eat that cheese. And by cheese, I mean my pussy.' I couldn’t help myself and replied that I’m lactose intolerant."

u/Teazykatka

9."I was the weird one. I’d start off by commenting about something in the background of a picture. If I couldn’t think of something funny, I’d just say, 'How do you feel about geese?' Most people have strong opinions."

A group of white geese gathered on a grassy field under a cloudy sky
Catherine Falls Commercial / Getty Images

10."'WHY DON'T YOU SKYDIVE INTO THIS PUSSY!!!' and then immediately unmatching me when I was like, 'Woah now...'"

u/Synamyn_Dyxon

11."They opened our initial conversation on PlentyofFish by asking for my detailed zombie apocalypse survival plan. I fell in love immediately. We've been married for almost 12 years now."

Several hands and arms reach out from a dark hollow within an old tree, adding an eerie and mysterious atmosphere
David Wall / Getty Images

12."'I want my wife to have your eyes.' I don’t think it was meant like that, but my first thought was that the dude wanted to cut out my eyeballs."

u/CurvyCarrots

13."I once got an opening message that said something like 'You might not be the prettiest girl on here, but beauty is only a light switch away.' This was over ten years ago, and I bet that dude is still single."

A close-up of a hand holding a smartphone, likely texting or browsing on it, set against a blurred background
Karl Tapales / Getty Images

14."A woman texted me on Bumble, 'fight me,' It was the weirdest but funniest first message I ever received."

u/gift_wrapist

15.And finally, “'No guillotine could take away the head I would give.' LOL."

u/Panamanianveganmeat

Have you ever received an incredibly weird first message on a dating app? Tell us what they said in the comments below: