People Couldn't Figure Out What Their Cookie Cutters Were Supposed To Be, And The Internet Hilariously Helped Out

If you've ever seen a cookie cutter and were left wondering just what in the world the shape was supposed to be, it turns out you're not alone. Luckily, the folks at the r/whatismycookiecutter subreddit are happy to help figure it out. Here are 5 odd cookie cutters and people's hilarious guesses, along with what they turned out to be:

1.This round, poky shape with some little points:

Cow-shaped cookie cutter on a light surface
u/duckpath / Via reddit.com

u/cpmatthew guessed, "A prancing pig with a bow in her hair."

A cartoon-style pink pig magnet with a playful expression and a red tuft on its head
u/cpmatthew / Via reddit.com

"Spaceship," guessed u/CogitoErgoBah.

Cartoon spaceship with a small red alien inside, visible through a transparent dome, features futuristic design elements
u/CogitoErgoBah / Via reddit.com

"Toddler dabbing in parachute pants," guessed u/Extension-Dot-4308.

Abstract cartoon figure with exaggerated features, wearing a blue outfit

Here's what it turned out to be:

Cookie cutter shaped like a koala with simple drawn details inside, sitting on a flat surface

2.This round-ish globby shape with a clawed arm of some kind:

Cookie cutter shaped like a seated dinosaur on a speckled countertop
u/x_ash_xx / Via reddit.com

u/RedCaio guessed, "Ballerina dives head first into couch cushions looking for her pocket change."

A pin showing a ballet dancer's foot in pointe shoe above a blue arm with a thumb up
RedCaio / Via reddit.com

"Worm escaping from a camera," guessed u/Milky_way3.

Cartoon-like drawing of a cat stuffed into a pot, with a sock-covered leg sticking out vertically
u/MIlky_way3 / Via reddit.com

u/VeryGayLopunny said, "Ho ho ho!"

Cartoon Santa Claus ornament with white beard and red suit lying on a gray, speckled surface

Here's what it turned out to be:

Cartoon drawing of a yellow excavator with "CAT" written on it, shown on a gravelly surface

3.This round, cup-like shape with a swoopy thing sticking up at the top:

Plastic cookie cutter shaped like a sitting cat on a textured surface
Plastic cookie cutter shaped like a sitting cat on a textured surface
Two cat-shaped cookies with icing question marks, next to a cat-shaped cookie cutter on a textured surface
Two cat-shaped cookies with icing question marks, next to a cat-shaped cookie cutter on a textured surface

u/Giorno_giovanna_wife / Via reddit.com

ADVERTISEMENT

"Cat working overtime at the dough factory!! It's rough this time of year," guessed u/winchesnutt.

Cartoon-style sticker of a black cat with green eyes and a pink nose, sitting on a cream-colored crescent shape
u/winchesnutt / Via reddit.com

u/KatyClaws guessed, "Rat in a tiny boat."

Cartoon sticker of a gray mouse sitting on a piece of brown cheese, depicted on a textured surface
u/KatyClaws / Via reddit.com

"It's a seal lounging like a sexy lady," said u/FunSushi-638.

Gray dolphin sticker with a white border on a textured surface
u/FunSushi-638 / Via reddit.com

Here's what it turned out to be:

Cartoon pirate ship sticker with a skull and crossbones on the sail, on a textured surface

4.This pointy shape with an appendage of some type:

Bird-shaped cookie cutter on a dark surface, with a small metal tool nearby
u/not_amurderer69 / Via reddit.com

u/JustForeverTired guessed, "Fat unicorn in bikini with a burning bum."

Cartoon unicorn-shaped pin wearing pink floral underpants on a dark surface

"A beautiful mermaid," guessed u/PotatoCatastrophe.

Cartoon of a seal with human-like features, including arms and a torso, floating in a playful pose

u/Ok-Disaster-4320 said, "Shark bird... or bird shark?"

Cartoon shark-bird hybrid sticker with an open mouth, showing sharp teeth, placed on a dark surface

Here's what it turned out to be:

A sticker of a cartoon bird dressed as a witch with hat, glasses, and broom on a dark surface

5.And finally, this round, leaf-like shape:

A hand holds a ghost-shaped cookie cutter, with store shelves in the background
u/Dapper-Slip-4093 / Via reddit.com

"It's the squeekin' pope," said u/Cleansweepy.

Cartoon of a rat dressed in a pope-like robe with a mitre, appearing to gesture or speak animatedly
u/Cleansweepy / Via reddit.com

u/my_names_is_billy guessed, "Some sort of bird or duck."

Cartoon drawing of a yellow duck with an orange beak, standing on blue water with green reeds, held by a person indoors

"Keebler Elf bathing," said u/RedCaio.

Cartoon of an elf wearing a shower cap, happily bathing in a clawfoot tub with bubbles, set against a textured background
u/RedCaio / Via reddit.com

Here's what it turned out to be:

Santa emoji overlay on shopping cart handle, resembling a sleigh with festive details

I have to know: would you have had any idea what these cookie cutters were without help? And do you have any weird cookie cutters in your collection that you can't quite identify? Let us know in the comments.