“Mean Girls” Alums Lindsay Lohan and Lacey Chabert Look Back at Their 'Fetch' Y2K Fashions

The duo appeared on 'Watch What Happens Live' to review some of their most iconic looks

Lindsay Lohan and Lacey Chabert are taking a trip down memory lane.

On the Wednesday, Nov. 20 episode of Bravo's Watch What Happens Live, the Mean Girls alums retunited to look back at some of their early 2000s fashion moments.

In a game of "So Fetch or That's Retch?", the actresses were shown photos of their outfits and had to decide if they were "so fetch" or, as host Andy Cohen put it in reference to the iconic 2004 movie, "the ugliest effing thing you've ever seen."

Cohen, 56, first pulled up a photo of Lohan, 38, at the premiere of Freaky Friday in 2003. "That's fetch," the actress said immediately about the black and metallic cocktail dress featuring a ribbon detail.

Chabert agreed, calling the look "adorable."

Lohan was then shown a photo of herself in a turquoise dress at the 2004 Mean Girls world premiere. "I loved this," she said of the bright ensemble, adding, "I think the spray tan wasn't necessary. I was a little orange."

First up for Chabert was a throwback from 2001 in which the Hallmark star wore a fitted floral-patterned shirt with three-quarter sleeves which she teamed with dark wash low-rise jeans.

The PEOPLE Puzzler crossword is here! How quickly can you solve it? Play now!

Related: Lindsay Lohan and Lacey Chabert Reprise Their Mean Girls Roles on WWHL — with Andy Cohen as Regina George

"Wow. Thank you so much for bringing up that picture," she joked. "I'm gonna go with retch, but it was well-intended."

Cohen chimed in saying, "In it's time, it was perfect."

During the segment, Lohan and Chabert also reprised their roles as Cady Heron and Gretchen Wieners, respectively, rom the team comedy movie. To recreate the beginning cafeteria scene, Cohen wore a wig to portray Regina George (famously played by Rachel McAdams ), storming off and saying, "Whatever, I'm getting cheese fries as Chabert and Lohan laughed.

Chabert continued the reenactment, delivering her iconic line: "Ex-boyfriends are off limits to friends — that's just, like, the rules of feminism!"

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

The former costars reunited last year for a Mean Girls-inspired Walmart Black Friday ad, which also featured fellow alums Amanda Seyfried (who played Karen Smith), Daniel Franzese (who played Damian) and Rajiv Surendra (who played Kevin).

McAdams, 46, did not appear, but in April, a source told PEOPLE that she and Lohan would be open to making a sequel to the original film, which was written by Tina Fey.