While discussing Chris Hemsworth's birthday and the formal photo that was shared by one of the star's friends, Brooke revealed she had Karl's formal photo in celebration of his birthday.
"It's another birthday today, one Karl Stefanovic," Brooke said. "I managed to dig out Karl's formal photo... Look how handsome he is!"
"That was Nola, g'day Nola!" Karl said, adding, "She only agreed to come on the day of the formal, because I couldn't get a date!"
"Aw, but why, look, you were so cute back then!" Ally said.
"You look like a cute couple," Brooke agreed.
"I wasn't really into chicks, you know?" Karl said, not realising how it sounded.
Ally and Brooke were surprised by the admission, with Karl immediately realising what he'd said.
"What?" Brooke laughed.
Karl attempted to explain himself but was laughing too hard, "I mean... I mean... I was into sport!"
"Oh my God," he managed to add through the laughter.
"I mean, whatever works!" Ally told him. "Whatever you want!"
"No judgement," Brooke added.
"You do love the shot of Chris Hemsworth," Ally joked.
"I feel like there have been some real revelations at the desk this morning, I hope Jas isn't at home watching," Brooke added of Karl's wife Jasmine Yarbrough.
"She's already texted and she's not that surprised," Ally quipped.
Instagram users found the mistake hilarious with one user writing, "'I wasn’t really into chicks,' you’ve outdone yourself Karlos, happy birthday legend!!"
"Learning some new stuff about you, Karl happy birthday sir," another said.
"Oh Karlos, this was gold this morning! Happy birthday and keep the laughs coming," a third wrote.
"Happy birthday Karl, you make me laugh every morning!" someone else added.
Jasmine also commented on the video, with four laughing emojis.
Never miss a thing. Sign up to Yahoo Lifestyle’s daily newsletter.
Or if you have a story idea, email us at firstname.lastname@example.org.