J.Crew is our editors' secret source for stylish winter coats — and our faves are on sale

I've been wearing an older navy version of this ultra-chic coat for over two years now. It's my go-to anytime I'm headed somewhere dressy that I feel like my puffer just won't cut it. Plus, it’s perfect for throwing on over my pajamas when I'm walking my dog on chilly mornings. It really helps me feel a bit more pulled together, like I've got my life sorted out. Made almost entirely from wool, the coat is warm and has spacious pockets to hold my gloves and cellphone.

I bought my normal size and it fits like a dream. I still have plenty of room to layer chunky sweaters underneath without feeling constricted or bulky. And can we talk about its durability? After two years, it still looks as good as new. It's dry clean only, but I've only had to take it in once for a refresh, so you won't be hit with a ton of extra cleaning bills. Every color is on sale right now and you can get an extra 50% off on certain styles when you use the code EXTRA.

You might think dressy coats won't offer the same amount of warm as a insulted parka, but our Gifting Editor Amanda Garrity says she's worn this topper in freezing cold New York and felt perfectly warm—though she does like to layer up underneath and add a scarf for extra coziness. This chic wool-blend coat features a zip closure with a storm flap to keep the wind at bay, plus a high-neck standing collar that Amanda says really “locks in warmth.”

It's available in regular, petite, and tall sizes, and since Amanda is 5'2", she opted for the petite size, which hits her mid-thigh — much more flattering than the regular length that ends around the knees. She says it's a great layering piece and looks good with pants and longer dresses and skirts. She did note, however: "If I'm wearing a shorter dress, I tend to go with a longer jacket." 

Overall, Amanda adores the boxy style and the gold buttons that add a touch of elegance to the winter jacket. It's normally priced at $348, which is a bit of a splurge, so she definitely recommends waiting for a sale (like right now!) to grab one at a better price.

"I purchased this coat a few years ago and it became an instant wardrobe staple," our Senior Commerce Writer, Kristen Granero tells us. "The fit is roomy enough to fit over thick sweaters (like for when you need more cushion in winter), but doesn't look loose or sloppy when thrown over a blouse or something lighter. It keeps form whether buttoned or unbuttoned and the material hasn't pilled or stained despite regular wear (when I've spilled water or coffee on it, I've been able to wipe it right off)."

Kristen purchased the 100% wool coat in the Heather Camel shade and says it has proven really versatile as she's able to wear it with everything else in her cold-weather wardrobe. But the coat is still available in certain sizes in gray, black, navy, pink and green — all of which are currently on double discounts.

Another favorite of Kristen's is this adorable faux-fur cropped jacket. "I was on the hunt for a dressy, faux fur coat that could be worn with dresses, or to dress up a pair of pants, and this jacket is it," she says. It's fitted so it's not too bulky, but she says it's still roomy enough to move around in.

"It looks good buttoned or open and comes in different shades, as well as a leopard pattern. I own the black but will likely add another color to my collection given how much I've enjoyed it and how many compliments I've received." If you're interested, Kristin recommends acting quickly, as this one tends to sell out. If you can't find your size and desired color in stock right now, check out the sweater version of the Lady Jacket. Our team is also a fan of that lighter style.

Aptly dubbed the "Lady Day" coat, this feminine topper is cinched at the waist to help show off your figure. Crafted from a luxurious wool blend sourced from Italy's Manifattura di Carmignano mill (which, according to the brand, is "known the world over for its exceptional woolen fabrics"), this sleek coat features a hidden button closure for a clean look. Plus, it's lined with Thinsulate for added warmth without all the bulk.

With a simple straight silhouette, V-neck collar and single-breasted buttons, you can't go wrong with this classic winter topper. It has welt pockets to hold your stuff and is made from melton wool, a fabric blend that's known for its durability and weather-resistance.

Love the look of a stylish fur coat but want it to be cruelty-free? Check out this luxurious faux option. It combines the cozy fuzzy texture with a classic peacoat-inspired silhouette for a high-fashion twist. Be sure to snag one while you still can, it's on final sale.

Barn coats had a resurgence this fall and this long version will help you continue to rock the trend as the temps continue to dip. The longer style will help block out wind — though since it's technically not a winter coat, we suggest layering it up underneath.

Amanda's favorite winter dress coat also comes in a longer version if you prefer more coverage and it's on sale too! The cocoon coat has all the same details as the above Toscana style but it hits below the knee to help lock in warmth.