Jason Kelce Jokes He Tells His Daughters Cats Are ‘Poisonous’ So They Won’t Want One

“Kylie is like, ‘They're not poisonous. Your dad is lying to you,’ ” the retired NFL star revealed of his wife on the latest episode of his 'New Heights' podcast

Jason Kelce is not a cat person.

The retired Philadephia Eagles player, 36, shared on the latest episode of his New Heights with Jason and Travis Kelce podcast, released Sept 3, that he told his daughters that cats “are poisonous” in an attempt to stop them from bringing a feline home.

“You know what my latest plan to divert our family from getting a cat is? I just keep telling our girls that cats are poisonous,” Jason revealed, referring to his three daughters Wyatt, 4, Elliotte, 3, and Bennett, 18 months, whom he shares with his wife Kylie Kelce.

“Why the f--- would you tell them that?” his brother Travis Kelce, 34, asked.

"... So that they don't want cats,” explained Jason. “And I don't have to deal with having a cat and make them terrified.”

Related: Jason Kelce Reveals He and Wife Kylie ‘Want to Keep Living in Philadelphia’ Amid Eagles Retirement

“That’s sick,” Travis responded. Appearing unbothered, Jason said, "It's whatever. They'll find out — I think lying to your kids is important,” he jokingly added.

“Not in this regard,” Travis commented, laughing. “They're gonna go over a friend's house and f---ing scream bloody murder because they see a cat.”

“That's fine. That sounds like that person's house problem,” Jason continued.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Related: Jason Kelce Says the New Heights Podcast Audience Appreciates His 'Loving Relationship' with Brother Travis Kelce

Travis laughed some more as he labeled his big brother a “psycho” and said he was being “ridiculous.”

“I gotta get these kids on my side. Otherwise, I'm in a sinking ship,” Jason went on as he admitted his wife Kylie does not cosign his lies.

“Kylie is like, ‘They're not poisonous. Your dad is lying to you,’ ” the father of three shared. “I'm like, listen, If you have a cat, the government will come and take it from you because it's they're so lethal that I mean, they can kill you ... and they don't even have to bite you. Just them licking you.”

Despite growing up with cats, the retired NFL star shared that as he’s gotten older he no longer likes the furry companions.

“I just don't want a cat,” Jason continued. “I don't want another animal in the house. My dogs have already ruined the furniture.”

Jason finally added that cats are “fine if they stay outside,” before coming up with the compromise of having an outdoor cat should his girls still want one.

“I'll do an outdoor cat. I'm okay with an outdoor cat,” he added.

The PEOPLE Puzzler crossword is here! How quickly can you solve it? Play now!

Jason comments come after Kylie, 32, asked for Travis' help in convincing Jason to get a cat in a December 2023 episode of the brothers' podcast.

"No, here's the deal, I told Jason that I want to get a cat," Kylie said. "And he told me no. And I feel like you might like cats now."

"What color cat do you want?" Travis replied.

"I don't want you to send a cat. I just want you to get on my team here," Kylie told her brother-in-law, adding that she asked because she thought Travis "might like cats now."

Travis' girlfriend Taylor Swift is a cat lover, with the pop superstar being a proud cat mom to three felines — Meredith Grey, Olivia Benson, and Benjamin Button.

For more People news, make sure to sign up for our newsletter!

Read the original article on People.