‘All In: Comedy About Love’ Recoups Broadway Capitalization, Producers Announce 2025-26 Sequel

Greg Evans

18 February 2025 at 10:23 am·2-min read

All In: Comedy About Love, the hit Simon Rich play in which a rotating cast of stars read-performed the author’s comic stories, recouped its Broadway capitalization before playing its final performance on Sunday, February 16 at the Hudson Theatre, producers announced.

In fact, the production was so successful – it holds the Hudson’s house record for the weekly highest gross – that producers Seaview and Lorne Michaels have announced a “companion piece” by Rich to hit Broadway next season: All Out: Comedy About Life.

More from Deadline

Venue and “all-star casting” for All Out will be announced soon. All In director Alex Timbers will return for All Out.

“I’m so grateful to have had the chance to collaborate with so many talented people on All In: Comedy About Love,” Rich said, “and I’m thrilled to be working with the same creative team on my next show All Out: Comedy About Life, the companion piece to All In. It’s about ambition, envy, ego, spite, and the blind pursuit of fame and fortune. I think some New Yorkers might find the theme even more relatable than love.”

All In holds the record for the weekly highest grossing play in the history of the Hudson Theatre for the week ending February 2, 2025. That was the week Jimmy Fallon guest starred, with the weekly gross hitting a Hudson record of $2,080,707.

The production’s first cast was John Mulaney, Fred Armisen, Renée Elise Goldsberry, and Richard Kind, with subsequent casts taking over for limited engagements including Lin-Manuel Miranda, Annaleigh Ashford, Hank Azaria, Aidy Bryant, David Cross and Fallon.

The 10-week run began previews on December 11, 2024 and officially opened December 22.

All Out will be produced on Broadway by Seaview and Lorne Michaels. Micah Frank and Caroline Maroney will produce on behalf of Broadway Video. General Management is by Wagner Johnson Productions, and casting is by Taylor Williams, CSA.

Best of Deadline

The Independent
Lifelong Democrat George Clooney issues surprising message to Donald Trump
Hollywood A-lister, who was raised a Democrat, supported Kamala Harris after urging Joe Biden to drop out of the race
HuffPost
Robert De Niro’s Politically Charged Answer Leaves ‘Late Show’ In Eerie Silence
The "Zero Day" star and "Late Show" host Stephen Colbert let a haunting silence hang in the air for several seconds.
Yahoo Lifestyle
Hugh Jackman and Sutton Foster 'relieved and happy' amid Deborra Lee Furness' snarky prediction
Hugh Jackman and Sutton Foster are said to be 'relieved and happy' that they no longer need to hide their relationship. Read more.
Hello!
Victoria Beckham poses up a storm as she shares rare photo of David Beckham's two sisters
Victoria Beckham stunned her followers on Wednesday when the wife of David Beckham shared a gorgeous photo alongside Joanne and Lynne Beckham
The Daily Beast
‘Long Live the King!’: Trump Says Quiet Part Out Loud
President Donald Trump has proclaimed himself the savior of Gotham. The president made the astonishing declaration while patting himself on the back for pulling the plug on a controversial New York City toll plan Wednesday. “CONGESTION PRICING IS DEAD. Manhattan, and all of New York, is SAVED. LONG LIVE THE KING!” he wrote in a post on Truth Social.
BuzzFeed
"It's Actually About A Really Dark, Sad Thing": Adam Lambert Recalled The Time He Had To Scold An Audience Member For Laughing At A Grim Moment During "Cabaret"
"I stopped, and I just looked at the audience, and said, 'No.'"
Entertainment Weekly
Heather Locklear recalls her “Melrose Place ”skirts getting shorter: 'I could almost feel my crack'
And no pantyhose or "granny panties" for Amanda Woodward.
WWD
Heidi Klum Stars in New PosheEra Campaign for ‘Magic Wand’ Shaving Tool, Talks Self Care Secrets
"It’s a magic wand that makes shaving so much easier."
InStyle
Prince William Knew Just What to Say When a Little Boy Asked If He Was King
Both William and his wife Kate Middleton have a way with kids.
Sky News
Northumberland: Burglar who triggered 'Home Alone-style trap' is jailed
A burglar who was caught after triggering a Home Alone-style trap at a house in Northumberland has been jailed. Paul Howell, 56, was attempting to break into a property in Blyth - but fled when a bucket of water soaked his feet after tripping a hidden line of string just before 3am on 9 November last year, police said. In the 1990 movie Home Alone, eight-year-old Kevin McCallister, played by Macaulay Culkin, set a series of elaborate traps for two bungling burglars after his family accidentally left him by himself in their Chicago house at Christmas.
Parade
King Charles Makes Rare Comment About Son Prince Harry
The King does not often mention his youngest son amid their ongoing royal family rift.
The Independent
Donald Trump declares himself ‘king’ after striking down New York congestion pricing
Trump faces legal challenge after threatening to kill Manhattan toll that raises money for mass transit
Parade
Kim Kardashian Publicly Calls Out Mom Kris Jenner for Stealing Her Thunder
The SKIMS founder was not impressed by her mother's poorly-timed post.
Evening Standard
Kim Kardashian forced to admits North West is 'not a singer' as she defends daughter joining Lion King cast
The reality TV star has finally weighed-in on the nepo baby debate as she addressed hateful trolls
Parade
Jason Kelce Reveals a New Family Addition for Brother Travis
It's not clear whether Taylor Swift was involved.
The Daily Beast
Nicolas Cage’s Ex Files Lawsuit Against Him and His Son
Nicolas Cage’s ex-wife, Christina Fulton, is suing both the actor and their 34-year-old son Weston after the latter allegedly assaulted her last spring. While she’s accusing Weston of the attack, she’s also going after her ex-husband for his “negligent supervision.” Fulton claims that Cage enabled their son’s “manic rage” and ignored his mental health issues. Weston, an actor whose recent films include D-Day and Boneyard, was widely criticized last April for allegedly beating his mother. At the
The Independent
Trump hosts Black History Month event with Tiger Woods; Musk claims Zelensky is ‘despised’ in Ukraine: Live
President’s first four weeks in White House marked by turbulence at home and abroad
InStyle
All About Alec and Hilaria Baldwin's 8 Kids
Plus, how they're related to Hailey Bieber.
The Independent
Spectacular statues reveal art tradition of ancient Rome’s lost sculpture capital
City of Perga on Turkey’s southwestern Mediterranean coast was renowned in ancient world for production of marble statues
The Daily Beast
George Clooney Offers Surprise Message for Trump After Feud
George Clooney had an unexpected message for Donald Trump when he was asked about the president: “I hope you do well because our country needs it.” Clooney was among the cadre of Hollywood stars backing Kamala Harris in the 2024 election–after publicly switching his support from former President Joe Biden. He has also famously feuded with Trump, who branded him a “fake movie actor.”

Latest stories