Can you use non-alcoholic wine in your cooking?

If you’ve ever dabbled in cooking with wine, you know the drill: pick something tasty but not so expensive that you cry when you pour it into a sauce. However, this brings up an interesting question: can you replace wine in recipes with a non-alcoholic alternative, or is that a culinary no-no?

Even the most alcohol-loving foodies agree that cooking with wine is about the flavour, not the alcohol content. So, can a booze-free substitute really work the same magic in your dishes? This very question popped up in a popular recipe-sharing Facebook group, and let's just say, it stirred quite the debate.

RELATED:

• The surprising reason your thickened cream might not be whipping properly: 'Total fail'

• Apparently you're shelling your eggs all wrong: 'The mystery is solved!'

• The surprising ingredient behind dozens of budget-friendly meals: 'So good, quick and easy'

Will alcohol-free wine work the same in cooking?

"Has anyone used the alcohol-free wine from Woolworths in recipes?" asked the post. "I am assuming it would be the same but curious if people have used it." Alongside the query was an image of the Wolf Blass non-alcoholic Shiraz, which prompted diverse opinions and experiences from fellow cooks.

"Not the same taste," one member firmly stated. "Alcohol-free wine tends to be sweeter, almost grape juice-like. I wouldn't use it in cooking."

Another bluntly added, "It tastes horrible. I wouldn't use it for anything."

"I have used it as a red wine substitute to drink and it's revolting," someone else remarked, "Very, very sweet."

The case for non-alcoholic wine in cooking

Others were more positive about using a non-alcoholic beverage in their cooking, noting its improving quality and suitability for meals.

"I no longer drink alcohol, and while these zero wines aren't as enjoyable as the real thing, I am a fan of this Wolf Blass Shiraz and use it in my cooking and as a paired beverage," shared one member. "The quality of zero wines is improving every day. I recommend trying it to see what you enjoy."

"I had a sample of non-alcoholic red wine and used it to make lamb shanks and thought it tasted great," someone else said.

Some also suggested alternatives to both options, like simply using stock or wine vinegar for flavour instead.

Expert shares the truth about cooking with non-alcoholic wine

Meanwhile, a handful of group members pointed out the importance of alcohol for enhancing the flavour of a dish.

"Alcohol is actually a flavour carrier," argued one commenter, "the flavours in the dish are enhanced by it."

Many also stressed that the quality of the wine does matter. "You are cooking the alcohol out of it when you add it, so the actual flavour of the wine is important."

Indeed, according to Food Scientist Dr. Vincent, this perspective isn't far from the truth. He suggests that non-alcoholic wine may not measure up when it comes to enhancing your meal.

"While efforts are being made to improve the quality of non-alcoholic wines, they may still lack the depth and complexity found in traditional wines due to the absence of alcohol and differences in production processes," Dr. Vincent explained.

He pointed out several key differences:

1. Alcohol content: Alcohol contributes to the body and mouthfeel of traditional wines, which can affect the overall texture when replaced with non-alcoholic alternatives.

2. Fermentation process: Traditional wines undergo fermentation, contributing to their complex flavour profile, while non-alcoholic wines have the alcohol removed post-fermentation.

3. Solvent properties: Alcohol in traditional wines acts as a solvent, extracting flavours during maceration and fermentation, influencing the intensity of flavours in the final dish.

4. Ageing: Ageing in traditional wines enhances flavours and complexity, a process often omitted in non-alcoholic wine production.

5. Balance: Alcohol helps balance acidity and flavours in wine, which can be challenging to replicate in non-alcoholic versions.

SHOP:

• The 'amazing' dessert drink that's made with an unexpected ingredient: 'Nectar of the gods'

• Wine lovers can't get enough of this 'divine' socially conscious tipple: 'I don't feel guilty drinking it'

• The 'delicious' smoothie that's packed with protein: 'Such a great way to get added goodness'

Dr. Vincent also pointed out practical implications for cooking: "Alcohol can enhance and intensify flavours, whereas non-alcoholic wine may provide a different taste profile."

He noted that while the difference may be negligible in some recipes, it can be more noticeable in dishes where wine plays a major role, like coq au vin or beef bourguignon.

Want the latest celebrity news? Follow us on Facebook, Instagram and TikTok.