The Best & Battiest Moments From This Past Weekend’s Holiday Movies

Once again it’s the season to be merry and watch every new holiday movie as it debuts! Each Monday, we’ll take a look back at the previous weekend’s premieres to celebrate the most wonderful time of the year with a new list of superlatives.

More from TVLine

Best Musical Moment

Best Musical Moment
Best Musical Moment

The running joke of Pentatonix annoying their manager by responding in harmony in Netflix’s Meet Me Next Christmas was fun. But considering all the slow dances to Christmas carols we’ve sat through this season already, we appreciated the novelty of Layla (Christina Milian) and Teddy (Devale Ellis) performing a sexy lip-synch to “Santa Baby” the most. Plus, Layla’s sparkly jumpsuit was to die for.

Pet Peeve We’ll Stop Complaining About

Pet Peeve We’ll Stop Complaining About
Pet Peeve We’ll Stop Complaining About

As mentioned when we dubbed Hallmark Channel’s ‘Tis the Season to Be Irish our runner-up pick of the weekend, the film had a total disregard for the number of coats traveling house flipper Rose (Fiona Gubelmann) could have conceivably packed in her one suitcase. But, we will now acknowledge that the changing of coats is one way to tell the passing of days in winter movies with lots of outdoor scenes.

Safety Tip of the Week

Safety Tip of the Week
Safety Tip of the Week

In Hallmark Channel’s Santa Tell Me, interior designer Olivia (Erin Krakow) failed to check the license plate of the car she assumed was her ride share. Luckily, the man behind the wheel was just Chris (Krakow’s When Calls the Heart costar Daniel Lissing), the TV producer she was about to unknowingly trash talk to his face. At least she waited for the driver to speak her name first.

Biggest Reach

Biggest Reach
Biggest Reach

Olivia’s letter from Santa, informing her that she’d meet her soulmate, named Nick, was intentionally fantastical in Santa Tell Me. A plot point that we were supposed to accept as realistic: the viability in today’s economy of a shop devoted to wrapping presents bought elsewhere in Hallmark+’s Unwrapping Christmas: Tina’s Miracle.

Hallmark Debut of the Week

Hallmark Debut of the Week
Hallmark Debut of the Week

Eoin Macken (La Brea, The Night Shift) was ideal casting for realtor/preservationist/unofficial town mayor Sean in ‘Tis the Season to Be Irish, imbuing the character with enough charm, depth and sex appeal to not get upstaged by a hero sheep. Hallmark holiday movies can be a one-shot deal for that kind of established male actor. We hope we see him in another one next year (or perhaps moving to Lifetime or Netflix so he can show even more chest hair).

Biggest Overreaction

Biggest Overreaction
Biggest Overreaction

We all know there comes a time (with about 10 minutes left in the film) when the two people about to become a couple have a disagreement that could’ve been easily avoided or quickly cleared up. In Hallmark Mystery’s Five Gold Rings, Audrey (Holland Roden) learned that private eye Finn (Nolan Gerard Funk) was paid by her late grandmother to help her reunite those loosely defined treasures with their owners. Grandma had suggested Audrey enlist Finn’s services in the quest, and Audrey never doubted his noble intentions. She didn’t need to storm off!

Family Tradition We’re Most Tempted to Try

Family Tradition We’re Most Tempted to Try
Family Tradition We’re Most Tempted to Try

In Great American Family’s Christmas Under the Northern Lights, tour guide Trevor (Jesse Hutch) took urban historian Erin (Jill Wagner) into the Canadian wilderness to show her how generations of his family have hung bells on trees to represent themselves. The gentle clanging was beautiful. But how do you keep the bells from blowing away during a storm?

Most Romantic Moment

Most Romantic Moment
Most Romantic Moment

Producer Chris abusing his power to turn the home improvement network’s prop warehouse into a recreation of the starlit sleigh rides from Olivia’s youth was incredibly sweet in Santa Tell Me. Moral: You don’t need the northern lights for romance. You just need to show that you listened. See also: Max (Brant Daugherty) taking Celeste (Tammin Sursok) to build a Christmas village, like the ones she and her father used to make, in Hallmark Channel’s Trivia at St. Nick’s.

Funniest Scene

Funniest Scene
Funniest Scene

Cousin Jordy (scene-stealer Kalen Allen) barking choreography at Layla and Teddy in Meet Me Next Christmas wins. Honorable mentions: Olivia nearly maiming and concussing dates in Santa Tell Me. (Hallmark should do more physical comedy that doesn’t involve falling into someone’s arms.) And the ladies arming themselves with pans to answer a late-night doorbell and the lusty flirting from sister Lisa (Tiffany M. Snow) in BET+’s A Christmas Miracle.

Interior Decoration Debate of the Week

Interior Decoration Debate of the Week
Interior Decoration Debate of the Week

Does Tina’s dad (Henry Alessandroni) in Unwrapping Christmas: Tina’s Miracle, starring Natalie Hall, really need three poinsettias, two Christmas trees, one wreath and multiple garlands in his kitchen? It made Michael’s (Alec Santos) kitchen, with garland lining every inch of counter space, seem underdressed.

Exterior Decoration Debate of the Week

Exterior Decoration Debate of the Week
Exterior Decoration Debate of the Week

Should wealthy people living in skyscrapers be allowed to have projectiles on their patios, as seen in Meet Me Next Christmas?

Surest Sign the Times Are Changing

Surest Sign the Times Are Changing
Surest Sign the Times Are Changing

What a difference a decade makes. In 2014’s classic The Nine Lives of Christmas, Brandon Routh’s Zachary had to wear a red muscle tank while posing for a firefighters calendar. In Santa Tell Me, firefighter Nick C. (Kurt Szarka) was able to walk around shirtless for charity. Progress!

Sexiest Xmas Sweater

Sexiest Xmas Sweater
Sexiest Xmas Sweater

Just look at Max, offensive coordinator for the university football team, casually sitting on astronomy professor Celeste’s couch and enthusiastically watching a baking competition in Trivia at St. Nick’s. This pose was a slightly more subtle flex than him baring his bulging biceps for the team-bonding exercise at rock climbing wall.

New Christmas TV Movies to Watch in 2024
New Christmas TV Movies to Watch in 2024

Christmas Time Is Here! Your Guide to 100 Holiday Movies on Hallmark, Lifetime, Netflix and More in 2024

View List

Best of TVLine

Sign up for TVLine's Newsletter. For the latest news, follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.