Our Top 10 Most-Saved Casserole Recipes of All-Time

From budget-friendly casseroles to longtime family favorites, there is bound to be one (or more) you'll love.

Robin Shreeves

3 April 2025 at 10:00 am·4-min read

Key Takeaways

The list includes a variety of casseroles, from classic comfort foods like a taco bake to hearty chicken dinners like our a chicken and rice casserole.
What makes these casseroles stand out is their balance of simplicity, flavor, and ability to feed a crowd.
They often feature budget-friendly ingredients and are adaptable to various dietary preferences.

Out of all the countless casseroles we have here on Allrecipes, these are the 10 that our community members have saved the most. That means they're beloved by hundreds, maybe thousands, of home cooks who want to serve the most delicious dishes to their friends and families. From budget-friendly casseroles to longtime family favorites, there is bound to be one (or more) you'll love.

If there is a recipe that calls to you, save it to a collection using MyRecipes, a new home for all your favorite dishes. If you don't know about MyRecipes yet, sign up for it! And if you already have an Allrecipes account, you can use that same login for MyRecipes, too. It enables you keep all of your go-to recipes—from Allrecipes and other brands such as EatingWell, Better Homes & Gardens, and Food & Wine—all in one place.

Just tap the heart icon below under any recipe or on the recipe page below the author’s information to save it to your MyRecipes recipe box. Then, you can organize recipes into custom collections and find new ones you might not have come across yet. It's the easiest way to get cooking!

Related: How to Freeze Casseroles

Hamburger Potato Casserole

"This hamburger potato casserole is a recipe that my grandmother used to keep me and my finicky cousins well-fed," says Allrecipes member GRAVYCLAN. "It is very kid-friendly, and adults like it too!"

Get the Recipe

Chicken Noodle Casserole

"This is a new favorite for us! It is easy to throw together on a weeknight, and it's a hit with everyone in my family, including my picky pre-teen," says reviewer Cam3925. "I have made this both the 'fattening' way, and using the lower-fat soups and sour cream, and either way it comes out delicious."

Get the Recipe

Shipwreck Casserole

"This shipwreck casserole might not be pretty, but it is a tasty, busy-night, kid-friendly meal," says Allrecipes member Bcsgibson. "The prep time is generally limited to how fast your can opener works and how hard it is to unwrap your meat. The big bonus is that it's a complete one-pot meal!"

View the Recipe

Easy Mexican Casserole

Many home cooks added a packet of taco seasoning or homemade taco seasoning to this easy and delicious recipe, which is like nachos in casserole form. One reviewer called it "a go-to recipe forever!"

View the Recipe

Cheesy Amish Breakfast Casserole

View the Recipe

You can make this hash brown, bacon, and cheese casserole up to two days ahead before baking, which is one of the reasons everyone loves it. It's also very adaptable: Sub sausage for the bacon, switch up the cheeses, or add some veggies.

Grandma's Hamburger Casserole

"My grandmother's hamburger casserole is classic comfort food! Featuring ground beef, noodles, and a creamy cheese sauce, this simple recipe dates back to the 1940s," says Allrecipes member LaDonna Langwell. "You can tweak the amount of cheese and sour cream depending on what you've got in the fridge—it'll still turn out great!"

View the Recipe

Mamaw's Chicken and Rice Casserole

This easy and delicious casserole is perfect for weeknight dinners and potlucks. You can customize it by adding veggies (broccoli? peas?) and the cheese of your choice.

View the Recipe

Johnny Marzetti Casserole

"Kids love this Johnny Marzetti casserole. My mother-in-law used to make a simpler version of this for my husband when he was growing up," says Allrecipes member KC. "This version pushes the flavor profile a bit. Sometimes I let the casserole sit overnight before baking, as the flavors improve and the pasta absorbs some of the sauce, so the consistency is just right."

View the Recipe

Taco Bake Casserole

Shake up Taco Tuesday by making one big casserole. You can still add the fixings—shredded lettuce, sour cream, avocado, extra salsa—to individual portions so everyone can have it the way they like it.

View the Recipe