3."I'm going to go with Gary Oldman as Mason Verger in Hannibal. Not only was his real face buried under pounds of foam latex and silicone, but he also had one eye stretched open."
Here's Gary in real life vs. in the movie:
J. P. Aussenard / WireImage / Via Getty, MGM Distribution Co. / Via youtube.com
In 1993, Armin, who played one of the original Ferengi on Star Trek: The Next Generation and Quark the Ferengi on Deep Space Nine, told Desert News that the makeup took "only" three hours instead of the original four.
He said, "Up until the time that I played Quark, the Ferengi had no ear-holes in the makeup. So your ears were pinned back for the entire time you had the makeup on. And after about seven or eight hours, that got to be incredibly painful."
Here's J.G. Hertzler in real life vs. as a Klingon on Deep Space Nine:
At Central PA Comic-Con 2014, J.G. Hertzler, who played a Klingon, reportedly said his makeup process took about four hours. It required facial prosthetics, two wigs, and multiple layers of makeup.
Here's Marc Alaimo in real life vs. as a Cardassian on Deep Space Nine:
In 2017, makeup designer Michael Westmore told Trekyards that the Cardassians' makeup took three hours at first. He also said their look was inspired by the long neck of actor Marc Alaimo, who played the first Cardassian, as well as a painting of a woman with a spoon on her forehead at a local restaurant.
And here's Patrick Stewart in real life vs. as Locutus of Borg on Star Trek: The Next Generation:
11.And finally: "I would love to see Doug Jones represented on a list like this. Not only did he do *so many* iconic prosthetic performances, but they also run the spectrum from the creepy inhuman characters in Pan's Labyrinth to the far more emotive like Saru in Star Trek: Discovery, with stop-offs in between like the fish man in The Shape of Water."
In 2018, Doug told Fresh Air, "A head-to-toe transformation often you're looking at, yes, five hours is about right. The Fawn from Pan's Labyrinth, that was a five-hour makeup transformation. The Pale Man from Pan's Labyrinth, with my eyeballs in my hands — I did play that character as well — that was a six-hour transformation."
Here's Doug in real life vs. as Saru in Star Trek: Discovery:
Amanda Edwards / WireImage / Via Getty, CBS / Via youtube.com
Doug uses his extensive experience acting with facial prosthetics to help his costars who are new to it. On the Star Trek: Discovery set, he checked in with Mary Chieffo, who played the Klingon L'Rell, every day.
She told Indie Wire, "He was always there to grab coffee. Ultimately, we were lucky enough to have some great scenes together by the end of the season — it was so great to work with him on so many levels."
He offered her and other costars this advice: "Sit still, do as you're told, and find your happy place."
And here's Doug in real life vs. as the Amphibian Man in The Shape of Water:
Albert L. Ortega / Getty Images, Fox Searchlight Pictures / Via youtube.com
He told Fresh Air, "Shape of Water was much kinder and gentler — that was only three hours."
Now that we've talked about the best onscreen SFX makeup transformations, can you think of any you've seen that were laughably bad? What made them so unconvincing? Share your thoughts in the comments!
Note: Some responses have been edited for length/clarity.