Yahoo Life Shopping
Why you can trust us

We independently evaluate the products we review. When you buy via links on our site, we may receive compensation. Read more about how we vet products and deals.

I'm a pro baker: These are kitchen tools I'd never buy (and what to use instead)

Does anyone need a dedicated banana slicer? Spare me. Oh, and pizza scissors? Fun band name, unnecessary gadget.

a banana slicer with an
I'm a former pro baker who has lots of strong opinions about kitchen products — some of the items on this list are nothing short of laughable. (Amazon)

Do you have a sprawling kitchen, loaded with cabinets and drawers galore? I envy you. For the rest of us, maximizing our storage space means being strategic when it comes to cookware and gadget purchases — but with all of the new gizmos that are constantly popping up on social media and beyond, it can be tempting to add 'em to your cart in hopes that they'll save you time and effort.

As someone who used to bake for a living and now writes about kitchen items all day, I have a good grasp on the tools that are worth your money (and space) and those that, frankly, are nothing but quirky gimmicks (or just aren't very useful). Keep scrolling to see which products made the cut and, in my humble opinion, which ones you can feel free to skip.

❌ Never buy: Most metal cooking utensils

Not gonna lie: Seeing that metal spoon in a nonstick pan (above) is making me cringe. While they certainly look nice, metal spatulas, tongs and spoons can scratch up nonstick and enameled cooking vessels, so I tend to steer clear of them. I'll occasionally use a metal whisk if I'm mixing something in a bowl, but in general, the silicone variety is a safer bet (and won't rust!). 

$34 at Amazon

✅ Instead: Silicone cooking utensils

Speaking of... I'm a big fan of the GIR — which stands for "Get It Right" — product line (as is Giada De Laurentiis). Their products are gentle and safe to use on all types of cookware, yet so sturdy that they work just as well as metal. They're also really aesthetically pleasing ... look at those colors!

$46 at Amazon

❌ Never buy: Electric citrus juicer

Unless you're trying to start your own OJ business, I wouldn't advise purchasing a citrus-juicing machine. I don't have a ton of cabinet space for storing an appliance — even a small one — that I'm not going to be reaching for on the daily. Plus, you still have to hold the orange or lemon half over the juicer, which means you're not really saving much time. This model does have a pulp control feature, but you could always just strain out the stuff you don't want when juicing by hand. In short, not worth the space or money. 

$24 at Amazon

✅ Instead: Manual citrus juicer

 I use this very juicer at home, and it's likely the only one I'll ever buy. I've used it on everything from limes to grapefruits, and by the time I'm done, there isn't a drop of juice left on the flesh. What I really like about it is the fact that it includes a collection bowl, and the lid is dotted with holes, allowing juice to flow through while trapping the seeds. I'm also a fan of its minimalist design and compact size — oh, and that it's made of bamboo fiber instead of plastic. 

$16 at Amazon

❌ Never buy: Measuring cups and spoons with printed measurements

Baking is an activity that requires a good amount of precision, and if you can't read the markings on your measuring tools, well, you don't really want to wing it by guessing which one you're using. I don't understand why they still make sets with markings that are printed on, since they often fade within a year of use. Next!

$12 at Amazon

✅ Instead: Measuring cups and spoons with engraved measurements

Ahh, etched-in markings — much better! With these, you won't ever risk using the wrong cup or spoon, and what's helpful about this set is that it includes both U.S. and metric measurements. It's also dishwasher-safe, and the handles have nonslip undersides for improved grip. 

$10 at Amazon

❌ Never buy: Banana slicer

"Oof, this is one tough banana," said exactly zero people in the history of the universe. Okay, I can't say with 100% certainty that it's never happened, but when was the last time you had trouble slicing a Chiquita? Exactly. Bananas are one of the easiest foods to cut, so while this gadget might save you 2 seconds of prep time, it'll waste valuable drawer space. 

$7 at Amazon

✅ Instead: Paring knife

Um, yeah, a paring knife will do the job just fine ... and you'll be able to use it for other tasks, like peeling produce. This trio, which features a wavy-edge paring knife for slicing bagels, breads and softer produce without squishing them down, a straight-edge paring knife for peeling, chopping and mincing, as well as a dedicated tomato knife, is chef-approved. (It made our roundup of the best knives and knife sets for 2024, tested by top chefs.)

$19 at Amazon

❌ Never buy: Pizza scissors

While this doodad might make a fun white elephant gift or stocking stuffer, I find it highly unnecessary. Many of us already have kitchen shears should we ever decide that snipping out slices of pizza is the way to go, and as far as the "protective server" is concerned? Just use that pancake flipper in your drawer if you're worried about burning your fingers. 

$26 at Amazon

✅ Instead: Pizza wheel

If it ain't broke, don't fix it, right? Not only will an old-school wheel cutter suffice when it comes to portioning out a pizza pie, it can also be used to trim pastry dough. This one can be cleaned in the dishwasher and has an ergonomically angled design, as well as a finger guard. You know, for protected serving...

$6 at Amazon

❌ Never buy: Batter dispenser

Squeezing a lever to release blobs of pancake batter might sound like fun, but finding space for one of these gizmos in your kitchen? Not so much. There are other ways to evenly portion out batter (more on that later), so if you're not a short-order cook, this is one invention you can skip. 

$21 at Amazon

✅ Instead: Cookie scoop

Whenever I make cupcakes or pancakes, I reach for a cookie scoop. This way, I know each serving will contain approximately the same amount of batter, and I can use it to portion out cookie dough as well. If I'm dealing with super runny batters that are more difficult to scoop, I'll use a good ol' ladle instead. 

$15 at Amazon

❌ Never buy: Pie shield

Burnt crusts are never fun, but a dedicated pie protector just isn't necessary when it comes to preventing over-browning. Because they're not adjustable, it's all or nothing with them, meaning they're not so helpful if your stove has a hot spot and you only need a small area protected. 

$13 at Amazon

✅ Instead: Aluminum foil

No, it's not as eco-friendly, but using a roll of the silver stuff (which you likely always have on hand) is my method of choice. You can tent the parts of the crust that are getting a little singed, as well as mold the foil to protect the pastry rim's shape.

$12 at Amazon

If you have Amazon Prime, you’ll get free shipping, of course. Not yet a member? No problem. You can sign up for your free 30-day trial here. (And by the way, those without Prime still get free shipping on orders of $35 or more.)

The reviews quoted above reflect the most recent versions at the time of publication.