Craig Conover Says Paige DeSorbo Asked Him Why He Didn't 'Try to Get Me Back' After Breakup: 'I Would Have Never Left'

Craig Conover used the Southern Charm season 10 reunion as an opportunity to catch up on events that occurred after filming wrapped — specifically, his breakup with Pagie DeSobro.

“She called me and broke up with me after Thanksgiving when Austen and I were about to do a live show,” Craig, 36, said during the first part of the reunion on Thursday, March 27.

Related: Craig Conover Says He and Paige DeSorbo Had a 'Great Sex Life' Before Breakup: 'Checked So Many Boxes'

While viewers have seen cracks in his relationship play out on both Southern Charm and Paige’s show Summer House, Craig said he didn’t witness any red flags firsthand. “When we were together in private is what I based our relationship off of, and there weren't signs,” the Sewing Down South founder said.

Host Andy Cohen asked Craig why he didn’t own up to the breakup when he appeared on Watch What Happens Live in mid-December if it happened just after Thanksgiving. Craig said he didn’t think the breakup “was real” at that point.

“This isn't like a, we broke up and it was over and I moved on with my life. We had been planning our life together for three years and she fantasized about the family and stuff,” Craig continued. “And so yes, I had been in a weird place throughout December for which we continued to talk throughout December.”

Craig reiterated that Paige broke up with him over the phone following a “great” Thanksgiving weekend together with her parents.

“She broke up with me on the phone call by saying, ‘I think we need to break up,’" Craig said. “I’m saying I didn't receive it like that.”

The PEOPLE Puzzler crossword is here! How quickly can you solve it? Play now!

In fact, Craig revealed that he went to Paige’s apartment in New York City after the Watch What Happens Live taping to talk about the status of their relationship.

“I went to her apartment to just be like, ‘What’s happening?’” Craig recalled. “And she was like, ‘I probably am making the worst mistake of my life, but I need to go find myself.’ And then like I asked, ‘Well what do you want me to do with the ring?’ And she’s like, ‘Well, keep it. Maybe we’ll get married at BravoCon.’”

Andy, 56, thought that sounded like a good idea, but Craig’s costar Molly O’Connell thought he received “a lot of mixed signals” from Paige.

“To me, the person that she's kind of been since the breakup isn't the person that I remember dating,” Craig said. “You know, she’s fighting with people in the comments, she’s starting to say mean stuff about me based on what the internet is saying. And I’m just like, I didn't do anything to you. Like um, sure I wasn’t a perfect boyfriend and I had a lot of s--- that I had to work out, but it's been an interesting breakup to say the least.”

The breakup only started to feel real to Craig when she received a shipment of his items from Paige.

“Two days before New Year’s, she texted me and said, ‘I just want you to know, you know, I talked about it on my podcast that we’re no longer together,’” he said, referring to her Dec. 30 announcement on Giggly Squad. “And then like, all my stuff just showed up on my porch one day. Like, then it became real.”

Related: Paige DeSorbo and Craig Conover's Relationship Timeline — From Their Best Moments On-Screen Together to Their Amicable Breakup

Craig also addressed the rumors about whether Paige left him for another man, saying he questioned the fashion influencer about it directly.

“She said, ‘Craig, I’m not talking or dating anyone.’ And then she said some crazy stuff,” Craig said. “Well, she ... It doesn't matter. It’s not crazy. She was just like, ‘Why didn’t you try to get me back?’ I was like, ‘I have been trying to get you back. That's not fair.’ And then she was like, ‘I think it's very clear that we both made the right decision.’ And I was like, ‘We didn't make this decision.’ I would have never left.”

When Andy asked Craig why he didn’t fight for Paige, the Pillow Talk author said he knew “you shouldn’t be with someone you have to beg to be with.” Craig added, “I just wish she would've been honest from the beginning.”

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Part 2 of the Southern Charm season 10 reunion airs Thursday, April 3, at 8 p.m. ET on Bravo.

Read the original article on People