It looks like Apple is scouring its Chinese App Store for any remaining services that may not sit well with Chinese censors. Two RSS reader apps, Reeder and Fiery Feeds, said this week that their iOS apps have been removed in China over content that deemed "illegal" by the local cyber watchdog.
Apps get banned in China for all sorts of reasons. Feed readers of RSS, or Real Simple Syndication, are particularly troubling to the authority because they fetch content from third-party websites, allowing users to bypass China's Great Firewall and reach otherwise forbidden information, though users have reported not all RSS apps can circumvent the elaborate censorship system.
Those who use RSS readers in China are scarce, as the majority of China's internet users -- 940 million as of late -- receive their dose of news through domestic services, from algorithmic news aggregators such as ByteDance's Toutiao and WeChat's built-in content subscription feature to apps of mainstream local outlets.
Major political events and regulatory changes can trigger new waves of app removals, but it's unclear why the two RSS feed readers were pulled this week. Inoreader, a similar service, was banned from Apple's Chinese App Store back in 2017. Feedly is also unavailable through the local App Store.
The history of China's crackdown on RSS dates back to 2007 when the authority launched a blanket ban on web-based RSS feed aggregators. The latest incidents could well be part of Apple's business-as-usual in China: cleaning up foreign information services operating outside Beijing's purview, regardless of their reach.
Prior to its ban, Fiery Feeds had about 1,000 monthly active users in China, it told TechCrunch. Its iOS version was available in China without the use of a VPN, though some of the synced services it supported were blocked. Apple could not be immediately reached for comment.
"It seems [the ban] comes from the Chinese government, so I do not see any use in appealing to Apple," said a spokesperson at Fiery Feeds.
Reeder's fourth edition had a total 100,000 downloads in China, with between 100 and 300 daily downloads in the weeks before the ban, the app's developer Silvio Rizzi told TechCrunch. Like Fiery Feeds, the Reeder iOS app could be used in China without a VPN. It could only access content that was not concurrently blocked by a browser in China.
Rizzi said he had tried reaching out to Apple, "not because I have any hopes to get Reeder 4 back into the store but more to get some clarification." Apple encouraged the developer to reach out to the Cyberspace Administration of China directly, according to a notice seen by TechCrunch.
Apple has in recent times come under fire for deferring to censorship demands from China, a major market for its smartphone and app sale. The behemoth has purged its Chinese App Store of VPN services, video games, and podcast apps that lacked local authorization. Podcasts must get on a local hosting service before Apple even considers distributing them to Chinese users. In other words, the iOS publishing procedure for apps and podcasts in China is increasingly subject to Beijing's scrutiny.
The story was updated on September 30, 2020 with comments from Reeder.