Why saying you 'always knew Phillip Schofield is gay' is homophobic

Adam Bloodworth is a journalist from London who writes about LGBTQ+ experiences and issues.

This is his day, not ours. Coming out, I should know, takes potentially years of your energy to work up to. It isn't an experience you want stolen or hijacked by anybody else.

And yet, when Phillip Schofield came out earlier today there was an audible murmur from a number of armchairs across the UK.

Phillip Schofield who has admitted he knew he was gay when he got married in 1993, but that he was "naive" to think he could suppress his sexuality.. Issue date: Sunday February 9, 2020. The co-host of ITV's This Morning came out on the show last Friday.
Phillip came out as gay over the weekend. Photo: Getty Images

"I always knew," they said on Twitter, as if Schofield had survived such a sustained period of closetedness on the tellybox by privately whingeing to a select few viewers about his secret sexuality.

Of course, no one knew. No one other than him, and perhaps his wife, Steph. Maybe his closest friends and family in the more recent days, months and years.

No one knew, because there is no way to know. I've met countless men that have presented as camp but have told me in great detail about their lusts for the opposite sex.

Those people may be camp but also straight, or they may be bisexual, or they may be queer - the umbrella term I prefer to use to describe people who feel different to 'straight' - but crucially, no-one else knows other than that person, regardless of what people may think, so it's important to hold back from sharing our assumptions.

It’s important because these assumptions may be very damaging as well as very wrong.

How damaging? Well, the assumption that someone is gay based upon the way they act (what else could you base this presumption about Schofield on?) is inherently homophobic.

As I said, lots of people who present as camp aren't gay, and vice versa, so to assume all camp-presenting people are gay is to reduce homosexuality to one specific ‘recognisable’ image, perhaps from certain TV shows.

It is likening all gay people to one particular gay trope.

But of course, gay people come in all shapes and sizes and look and act very differently.

So it's crucial to avoid reducing gay people to reductive, toxic stereotypes of campness.

Plus, as these individuals literally didn't "always know”, it's unfair that they steal the thunder away from Schofield by implying that his revelation is old news.

This isn't old news: this is probably the most important news to have left Schofield's mouth in the past decade, maybe two. It’s perhaps his biggest personal news since his children were born.

Much of his confidence as a gay man forming his new identity will hinge on the catharsis he will have felt when he told this story. Speaking his truth will help his pain be alleviated.

As he poignantly said in his statement: "Only by facing this, by being honest, can I hope to find peace in my mind and a way forward."

You didn't always know. At times like these, it's important to listen quietly rather than shout loudly. This is Phillip Schofield's story. His truth. Let him speak it himself.

Got a story tip or just want to get in touch? Email us at lifestyle.tips@verizonmedia.com