The Masked Singer’s Bluebell Revealed? The Judges Weigh In Ahead of Double Elimination (Exclusive)

What is Jenny McCarthy thinking? Or should we say, Watts is she thinking?

The Masked Singer returns Wednesday (Fox, 8/7c) after a brief World Series-induced hiatus, and as you’ll see in TVLine’s exclusive sneak peek of the episode, McCarthy thinks she has the Bluebell all figured out. The catch? As usual, she’s way off.

More from TVLine

Picking up on clues about a public breakup and a proud Australian heritage, McCarthy declares that it could be two-time Academy Award nominee Naomi Watts under that flowery exterior. And while it’s not an entirely illogical conclusion to reach, TVLine has another idea about the secret celebrity.

If we had to bet money, we’d guess that Bluebell is actually ’90s songbird Natalie Imbruglia. How did we reach that conclusion? For starters, Kelly Osbourne introduced Bluebell as her Masked Singer ambassador, and a simple Google search will show Osbourne and Imbruglia’s names alongside one another in plenty of tabloid headlines. The ripped photograph in her clue package could have been a nod to Imbruglia’s 1997 debut single “Torn,” while the phoenix is likely referencing her 2021 album Firebird.

Wednesday’s episode, aka ’60s Night, will end with a double elimination, revealing which remaining member of Group B — Bluebell, Goo or Wasp — will move on to the next round.

Masked Singer Season 12 Cast Revealed Spoilers
Masked Singer Season 12 Cast Revealed Spoilers

Masked Singer: Every Season 12 Celeb Revealed

View List

So far, Season 12 of The Masked Singer has eliminated and revealed six celebrities: Laverne Cox (Orange Is the New Black) as Chess Piece, late-night legend Andy Richter as Dust Bunny, NFL great John Elway as Leaf Sheep, singer-songwriter Paula Cole as Ship, Yvette Nicole Brown (Community) as Showbird and Marsai Martin (black-ish) as Woodpecker.

Hit PLAY on the video above to watch the judges attempt to figure out Bluebell, then drop a comment with your own guesses below. Who’s under there?!

Best of TVLine

Sign up for TVLine's Newsletter. For the latest news, follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.