Loaded Muffuletta Grilled Cheese Recipe

Ksenia Prints

8 June 2024 at 5:45 pm·7-min read

Side view of two slices of gooey, melty grilled cheese - Ksenia Prints/Tasting Table

It's hard to improve on a classic, but this loaded grilled cheese takes the New Orleans signature muffuletta sandwich and turns it into a gooey, stretchy grilled cheese that screams comfort food with every bite.

According to Ksenia Prints of At the Immigrant's Table, this iconic New Orleans sandwich originated from the city's Italian immigrant population, who developed it as a portable lunch option for workers. Traditionally, the muffuletta features a combination of Italian cured meats, cheeses, and a tangy olive salad all layered between two halves of sesame-topped Sicilian bread. The traditional meats and cheese often included soppressata (Italian dried salami), mortadella (Italian cooked pork sausage), and capicola (Italian dry-cured ham).

Our loaded muffuletta grilled cheese takes this iconic sandwich to new heights by incorporating tangy giardiniera pickles and two kinds of cheese — provolone and mozzarella — for maximum cheese pull. This grilled cheese creation pays homage to the rich culinary heritage of the muffuletta while offering a deliciously indulgent twist anyone can get behind.

Gather The Ingredients For This Loaded Muffuletta Grilled Cheese

muffuletta grilled cheese ingredients - Ksenia Prints/Tasting Table

To make this muffuletta sandwich, you'll need an assortment of ingredients that represent the best of Italian cuisine. From your nearest Italian deli or well-stocked market, you'll want to grab giardiniera pickles, roasted red bell peppers, pitted black and green olives, garlic cloves, lemon zest, and olive oil to create the tangy, briny olive salad that is the signature component of this iconic sandwich. You'll also need a piece of focaccia bread, provolone and mozzarella cheeses, soppressata, mortadella, and capicola to layer between the bread, creating a harmonious blend of savory and melty textures. If you cannot find one or all of these deli meats, feel free to choose any cured, dried, and fresh deli meats made from pork and beef.

Step 1: Process The Spread

Olive spread in food processor - Ksenia Prints/Tasting Table

Prepare the olive spread: In a food processor, pulse the giardiniera pickles, roasted bell pepper, black olives, green olives, garlic, lemon zest, and olive oil until they are roughly minced but still chunky.

Step 2: Slice The Focaccia

Focaccia sliced in half - Ksenia Prints/Tasting Table

Slice the focaccia bread horizontally to create a top and bottom layer.

Step 3: Spread The Olive Mixture

Olive spread on two pieces of bread - Ksenia Prints/Tasting Table

Spread the olive mixture evenly on both sides of the focaccia.

Step 4: Layer The Bottom Half

Layering meat and cheese - Ksenia Prints/Tasting Table

Layer the bottom half of the focaccia with half of the provolone, half of the mozzarella, and all of the soppressata, mortadella, and capicola. Top with the remaining provolone and mozzarella.

Step 5: Close The Sandwich

Closing sandwich with other half - Ksenia Prints/Tasting Table

Close the sandwich with the top half of the focaccia.

Step 6: Heat A Cast Iron Skillet

Cast iron pan preheated - Ksenia Prints/Tasting Table

Heat a cast iron pan over medium-high heat.

Step 7: Brush The Sandwich With Oil

Brushing focaccia sandwich with oil - Ksenia Prints/Tasting Table

Brush the sandwich on both sides with more olive oil.

Step 8: Grill The Sandwich

Focaccia sandwich in pan - Ksenia Prints/Tasting Table

Grill the sandwich pieces on the heated cast iron pan until the cheese melts and the bread is crispy, about 5 minutes per side.

Step 9: Flatten The Sandwich

Pressed sandwich in pan - Ksenia Prints/Tasting Table

Press from above with another pan to flatten the sandwich.

Step 10: Cut Sandwich In Half

Cutting grilled cheese in half - Ksenia Prints/Tasting Table

Cut the large focaccia sandwich into two halves.

Step 11: Serve Hot

A person holding two slices of grilled cheese besides pickle spread - Ksenia Prints/Tasting Table

Serve hot.

What Is Giardiniera, And What Can I Use As A Substitute?

Side view of two slices of gooey, melty grilled cheese besides giardiniera spread - Ksenia Prints/Tasting Table

Giardiniera is a classic Italian condiment consisting of pickled garden vegetables. Traditionally, it includes cauliflower, carrots, celery, bell peppers, and sometimes olives or hot peppers, all marinated in a vinegar-based brine with herbs and spices. The vegetables are cured in the brine, resulting in a tangy, slightly spicy, and crunchy relish that adds a burst of flavor to various dishes.

If you don't have giardiniera, there are several substitutes that you can use in this recipe. One option is to make your own quick-pickled vegetable mixture by thinly slicing bell peppers, carrots, and celery and marinating them in a vinegar solution with garlic, salt, and your preferred seasonings. Alternatively, you can use a store-bought mixture of pickled spicy peppers or antipasti. If you prefer a milder flavor, you can opt for a simple bread and butter pickle relish or dill pickle relish. Another option is to skip the giardiniera and simply make the spread with a combination of olives, roasted red peppers, and a spoonful of capers to replicate the briny, tangy flavor profile of the pickles.

Can I Make This Muffuletta Grilled Cheese Vegetarian?

You can make this muffuletta grilled cheese recipe vegetarian by swapping out the meat components for plant-based alternatives or simply omitting them altogether. One approach is to replace the cured meats with plant-based deli slices or strips made from soy, seitan, or other plant-based proteins. These can mimic the texture and savory umami flavor of the traditional meats. Alternatively, you can opt for grilled or roasted vegetables, such as eggplant, portobello mushrooms, or marinated artichoke hearts, which can provide a meaty texture and depth of flavor.

If you prefer to keep it simple, you can omit the meat components entirely and focus on the delicious combination of cheeses, the tangy olive salad, and the hearty focaccia bread. The giardiniera pickles and olive salad will still deliver a punch of briny, tangy flavors, while the cheeses will provide a rich, melty texture. The most important part of making this grilled cheese is to layer the ingredients thoughtfully, ensuring a balance of flavors and textures with each bite — we promise you won't even miss the meat.