These 15 "Agatha All Along" Theories Are Going Viral, And I Need To Know If You Agree With Them

Raven Ishak
·9-min read

🚨 There are obviously MASSIVE spoilers ahead for Agatha All Along, as well as WandaVision! 🚨

Last Wednesday, Agatha All Along dropped a MASSIVE character reveal during Episode 5 — and it has made people on Twitter (now known as X) incredibly excited.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @shelbbs247

ADVERTISEMENT

(If you don't know, go watch Agatha All Along right now before continuing to read!)

Now that the witch is out of the bag, people have been theorizing about what's going to happen in the final four episodes of the show. So, since Episode 6 is coming out this Wednesday, I figured I would gather some of the biggest Agatha All Along theories that have been circling Twitter to get you even more excited for the next episode.

1. First, in Agatha's trial in Episode 5, it's believed that Agatha's son, Nicholas Scratch, said, "Mama, stop," when he was alive, not as a ghost in the trial.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @softagatha

ADVERTISEMENT

2. It's also believed that the Salem Seven took control of Agatha's trial.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @__ChelseaLee__

3. Or that Agatha's trial wasn't a trial at all.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @MlLFSFlLM

ADVERTISEMENT

One of the reasons? Because the aspect ratio didn't change like it did in the other trials.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @filmshaven

Another reason? Because they didn't find the clue themselves like they did in the other trials.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @filmshaven

ADVERTISEMENT

4. Some people even say that Teen, aka Billy Maximoff, could be messing with the trials because he is the one who's found every clue/trial instruction so far.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @heartstperxjoe

5. A LOT of people believe that Agatha killed Alice on purpose.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @wandasattorney

6. But some people believe she didn't have control of her own powers.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @adhdbarbie421

7. However, some people are even saying that Billy killed Mrs. Hart and Alice.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @LizziesLizardd

This theory may be true because it seems Agatha noticed something on Mrs. Hart as she lightly leaned closer to her. Also, when she said, "I didn't think you had it in you," it's believed that she was referring to Teen, not Mrs. Hart.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @sapphosz

8. However, it's also theorized that Alice isn't dead because we see her "alive" in future trailer clips.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @thatoneblackdud

However, whatever is going on with Alice, people want to know whose hands are touching Alice's face in a future episode.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @houseofikaris

(It also seems these person's fingertips are black, which means this person could have — or did have if this scene is in the past — access to the Darkhold.)

9. Also, since we now know that Billy had his powers all along (pun?), people are saying that he was the one who put the sigil on himself three years ago.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @firecrackerriot

10. Talking about Billy Maximoff, it's believed his soul entered Billy Kaplan's body right when they both passed away.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @giselleb1234

This theory might stick because of the conversation Rio and Agatha had earlier in the season.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @fletchersrosie

11. However, some people believe Billy is looking for Rebecca Kaplan (his biological mom) and not Wanda at the end of the road, since he lied about wanting to gain powers earlier in the season.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @CovenofChaoss

12. As for the next trials, some people say that Lilia is going to be the next witch to die.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @agathasbike

This theory might be true because it's seen here that Lilia and Rio are not with the rest of the gang.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @scarsirko

13. Talking about Rio, SO MANY people believe she is Death.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @Jessmuir0407

(Her name literally translates to River of Life — but maybe there's more to it?)

Reason #1: She never seems afraid when shit goes down.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @jefferyyjames

Reason #2: She cackled when they spelled the word "DEATH" on the Ouija board.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @GabiMG_News

Reason #3: It seems Agatha begged Rio not to take Teen after he got injured during the fire trial.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @fzztsylvie

14. Which may explain this theory about Agatha, Nick Scratch, and Rio.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @BriAlyse23

15. Another theory about these three? That Nick is actually Agatha and Rio's son.

Marvel / Via Twitter: @scarletfication

So, do you agree with any of these Agatha All Along theories? Or, do you have any theories of your own? Tell us what you think in the comments below.