If You Can't Place The Actors In "Monsters: The Lyle And Erik Menendez Story,"' Here’s Your Guide To Where You've Seen Them

Monsters: The Lyle And Erik Menendez Story premiered on Netflix on September 19th, and it's already causing quite the controversy.

Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story is about the notorious case of two brothers convicted of murdering their parents, José and Mary Louise "Kitty" Menendez, inside their home. Erik was 18 at the time, and Lyle was 22. In 1996, they were found guilty of first-degree murder and were given a life sentence without the possibility of parole.

Menendez brothers, Lyle and Erik, in a courtroom wearing blue prison uniforms, sitting at a wooden table during their trial
Ted Soqui / Sygma via Getty Images

The new series, created by Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan, revolves around the brutal slayings. Here are the cast members portraying real-life people:

Nicholas Alexander Chavez portrays Lyle Menendez (one of the brothers).

Nicholas Alexander Chavez at a film premiere wearing a brown suit with a white dress shirt
Kevin Winter / Getty Images

He also starred in the TV series General Hospital (2021-2024), playing Spencer Cassadine.

A person stands indoors, wearing a formal suit and tie
Christine Bartolucci / ABC via Getty Images

Cooper Koch portrays Erik Menendez (one of the brothers).

Cooper Koch in a black suit and tie with neatly styled hair, standing at an event
Steve Granitz / FilmMagic / Via Getty Images

He also starred in the horror film Swallowed (2022), playing Benjamin.

Cooper Koch is smiling and holding up his hand in a dimly lit setting with colorful lights in the background.
Momentum Pictures / Via youtube.com

Javier Bardem portrays José Menendez (Erik and Lyle’s father).

Javier Bardem, in a white shirt and dark blazer, smiles while posing in front of a dark background
Leon Bennett / WireImage / Via Getty Images

He also appeared in the movie Mother! (2017), where he played the character Him.

Javier Bardem with a serious expression, wearing a casual shirt, looking towards the camera in an indoor setting with a table and chair in the background

Chloë Sevigny portrays Mary Louise “Kitty” Menendez (Erik and Lyle’s mother).

Chloë Sevigny at the 'Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story' event, wearing a large, oversized jacket
Kevin Winter / Getty Images

She's also starred in the TV series The Girl from Plainville (2022), playing Lynn Roy.

Chloë Sevigny with others sit attentively watching something in the background

Nathan Lane portrays Dominick Dunne (an investigative journalist).

A person wearing glasses and a suit is smiling while looking to the side
Leon Bennett / WireImage / Via Getty Images

He also starred in the TV series The Gilded Age (2022-2023), playing Ward McAllister.

Nathan Lane dressed in a 19th-century suit with a cravat, smiling and standing inside a period-style room

Ari Graynor portrays Leslie Abramson (criminal defense attorney and lead counsel for Erik Menendez).

Ari Graynor with long wavy hair, wearing a strapless dress and large earrings, smiles at the camera.
Steve Granitz / FilmMagic / Via Getty Images

She also starred in the movie For a Good Time, Call... (2012), as the character Katie Steel.

Two women, one with long dark hair and another with blonde hair wearing a floral robe, are sitting closely and talking, appearing to be in a serious conversation

Dallas Roberts portrays Dr. Jerome Oziel (the therapist of Erik Menendez).

Man in dark shirt stands in front of Netflix's "Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story" promotional backdrop
Roy Rochlin / Getty Images for Netflix

He also starred in the TV series Insatiable (2018-2019) as the character Bob Armstrong.

Debby Ryan stands beside Dallas Roberts in a plaid blazer, holding a drink. Both appear to be engaged in a serious conversation indoors

Leslie Grossman portrays Judalon Smyth (mistress of Dr. Jerome Oziel and a key witness in the case).

Leslie Grossman on the red carpet, wearing a long black lace dress and holding a black clutch, at the premiere of "Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story."
Leon Bennett / WireImage / Via Getty Images

She's also appeared in American Horror Story (2017-2024), playing various characters, including Margaret Booth in AHS 1984.

Leslie Grossman is sitting indoors, wearing a beige vest over a white shirt, with glasses and wavy shoulder-length hair. She appears to be in a serious moment

Jason Butler Harner portrays Les Zoeller (Beverly Hills PD detective and prime investigator in the Menendez case).

Jason Butler Harner stands in front of a promotional background. He is wearing a tan blazer over a white shirt and white pants. His hair is styled, and he has a slight smile
Steve Granitz / FilmMagic / Via Getty Images

He's also starred in the TV series Ozark (2017), playing Roy Petty.

Two men are conversing in a dimly lit room, one wearing a baseball cap and the other, Pedro Pascal, is touching the other man's neck

Enrique Murciano portrays Carlos Baralt (Lyle and Erik’s uncle and brother-in-law to Jose Menendez).

Enrique Murciano  in a striped T-shirt, floral-patterned coat, and tinted glasses poses at a Netflix event
Leon Bennett / WireImage / Via Getty Images

He's also starred in the TV series The Night Agent (2023), playing Ben Almora.

Enrique Murciano and another man are having a conversation.

Michael Gladis portrays Tim Rutten (Leslie Abramson's husband).

A bearded man in a suit and a woman in a casual blue dress smile on a red carpet at the "The Beauty Collection" event backdrop. Names of individuals not known
Unique Nicole / Getty Images

He's also appeared in the TV series Death and Other Details (2024), playing Keith Trubitksy.

Michael Gladis wearing sunglasses and a green shirt with a serious expression stands outside against a blue sky

Drew Powell portrays Detective Tom Linehan (detective on the case).

Drew Powell  smiling in front of a backdrop with text that reads "Pasadena Playhouse" and "Of the Ones."
Olivia Wong / Getty Images

He's also been seen in the TV series Gotham (2014-2018), playing the character of Butch Gilzean/Solomon Grundy.

Drew Powell, with blonde hair and wearing a sleeveless vest, stands in a dimly lit industrial setting, appearing concerned. Audience members are visible in the background

Charlie Hall portrays Craig Cignarelli (Erik's friend).

Four people pose for a photo against a backdrop that says "Tuesday." Names of the other people are unknown
Santiago Felipe / Getty Images

He's also been seen in the TV series Single Drunk Female (2022-2023), playing the character of Joel.

Charlie Hall with short hair, wearing a casual polo shirt, looks to his right in a dimly lit room with a fireplace in the background

Gil Ozeri portrays Dr. William Vicary (a psychiatrist).

Gil Ozeri  smiles, wearing a black turtleneck and gray checkered pants, standing in front of a Film Independent event backdrop
Amanda Edwards / Getty Images

He was also featured in #BlackAF (2022) as the character Danny.

Gil Ozeri with glasses and casual sweater looks up at a standing person. Natural background of plants visible through window.

Jeff Perry portrays Peter Hoffman (Jose's business partner).

An older man with short, grey hair wearing a dark blazer over a black shirt at an event with a backdrop that mentions "The Actors Fund" and "SCANDAL."
Michael Tran / Getty Images

He's also appeared on the TV series Scandal (2012-2018) as Cyrus.

Jeff Perry in a suit sits on a striped sofa, holding a folder and pen, appearing deep in thought. There are papers and a coffee cup nearby
Richard Cartwright / Disney General Entertainment Content via Getty Images

Tessa Auberjonois portrays Dr. Laurel Oziel (Jerome's wife).

Amy Brenneman poses in a floral-patterned dress on the red carpet for the 'Clue: On Stage' event, hosted by Center Theatre Group
Paul Archuleta / Getty Images

She's also starred in How I Met Your Father (2022-2023), playing Naomi.

Tessa Auberjonois sits at a desk, wearing a floral jacket over a white blouse.

Tanner Stine portrays Perry Berman (friend of Erik and Lyle and former tennis coach).

Tanner Stine  in a patterned white shirt and black pants stands on a red carpet with a YouTube Originals backdrop
Paul Archuleta / Getty Images

He's also starred in Days of Our Lives: Beyond Salem (2022), playing Joey Johnson.

Tanner Stine in a dark long-sleeve shirt, standing in a kitchen
Peacock / Evans Vestal Ward/Peacock via Getty Images

Larry Clarke portrays Brian Andersen (uncle of Lyle and Erik).

Larry Clarke in front of a movie poster featuring Eric Edelstein, Mo Gaffney, and Brian Dennehy
Paul Archuleta / Getty Images

He's also appeared in the TV series Heels (2021-2023), portraying Ted Day.

Three people are gathered around a kitchen table, including Larry Clarke, engaging in conversation and looking at a smartphone

Jade Pettyjohn portrays Jamie Pisarcik (dated Lyle and was a tennis pro).

Jade Pettyjohn in a tailored black suit with a plunging neckline poses on the Tribeca Festival red carpet
Cindy Ord / Getty Images for Tribeca Festival

She's also starred in the TV series Big Sky (2020-2021) as Grace Sullivan.

A person with wet hair looking up with a distressed expression

Marlene Forte portrays Marta Cano (Lyle and Erik's aunt).

Marlene Forte wearing a floral-patterned dress, standing in front of a backdrop with text graphics
Paul Archuleta / Getty Images

She also appeared in the TV series The Lincoln Lawyer (2022-2023), portraying the character of Judge Teresa Medina.

Marlene Forte  sits at the bench with an American flag and the seal of California behind her

And finally, Paul Adelstein portrays David Conn (prosecutor in the retrial of the Menendez brothers).

Paul Adelstein with a beard, wearing a green suit with a dark shirt and a green tie, poses for a photo in front of a dark backdrop
Michael Loccisano / WireImage / Via Getty Images

He also appeared in Cruel Summer (2023) as Steve Chambers.

Paul Adelstein and a woman face each other near a lake with mountains in the background

What do you think of the cast for Monsters: The Lyle And Erik Menendez Story? Let me know in the comments.