'I, Robot' Director Calls Out Elon Musk: 'Can I Have My Designs Back Please?'

Elon Musk may be viewed as a visionary by his fans, but perhaps not Alex Proyas.

After the Tesla CEO showed off his company’s Optimus robots and new self-driving vehicle designs last week in Burbank, California, the filmmaker suggested on Sunday that the products bore a resemblance to the technology seen in his 2004 science fiction blockbuster, “I, Robot.”

“Hey Elon,” Proyas wrote on Musk’s X platform, formerly known as Twitter. “Can I have my designs back please?”

The rhetorical question was accompanied by a triptych of “I, Robot” stills alongside products showcased at the Burbank event, which was titled “We, Robot.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Musk as yet to publicly respond to Proyas. But supporters of the right-wing billionaire seem to believe that Proyas’ question was out of line.

“Be honored. What you did with CGI and a green screen, @elonmusk did in reality,” wrote one user on X, referencing a handle used by Musk.

Another said, “you feel you inspired the future yet you’re trying to dunk on the person who made it a reality.”

Photos show an
Photos show an "I, Robot" design beside actor Will Smith, left, and a Tesla robot. Left: Roberto Pfeil/Associated Press; Right: Ying Tang/NurPhoto/Getty Images

Musk originally unveiled the Optimus robot in 2022, the same year that he acquired Twitter for about $44 billion. Though once lauded for his technological ambitions, Musk has recently lost much of his cultural cachet amid his outspoken views on politics.

For his part, Proyas was hailed as a visionary long before Musk — who at times has been accused of taking credit for other people’s efforts — became a household name.

ADVERTISEMENT

Though the screenplay for “I, Robot,” was based on the work of legendary sci-fi author Isaac Asimov, the film itself has been praised for its production design, including its depictions of futuristic vehicles and humanoid robots. “Dark City,” Proyas’ award-winning sci-fi thriller from 1998, also received acclaim for its designs and mind-bending ideas.

Meanwhile, Tesla’s Optimus robots were reportedly controlled in part by humans at “We, Robot.” Following last week’s event, the company’s stock dropped by nearly 9%.

Related...