TBH, movie remakes are always hit or miss. I'm usually a sucker for the original and that can often be hard to beat.
Klaus Vedfelt / Getty Images
When Reddit user Aaaaaaarrrrrggggghh asked, "Which movie should NEVER get a remake? " many people chimed in with their thoughts. Here are the fan-favorite films no one ever wants to see changed:
1. Titanic
"I don't want to see a CGI iceberg ruining the iconic handprint scene."
—u/gigglygumdrops
Merie W. Wallace / © 20th Century Fox Film Corp. / Courtesy Everett Collection 2. Pulp Fiction
"Pulp Fiction is iconic and any remake would just fall flat in comparison."
—u/GloomySwimmer9374
© Miramax / Courtesy Everett Collection 3. Jurassic Park
"The original film still holds up, and aside from more accuracies in the dinos, there's not much to be gained."
—u/jabber2033
"Jurassic Park was groundbreaking and still holds up today. Leave those dinosaurs alone."
—u/InLoveWmorningD
© Universal / Courtesy Everett Collection 4. The Breakfast Club
© Universal / Courtesy Everett Collection 5. Forrest Gump
© Paramount / Courtesy Everett Collection 6. Ferris Bueller's Day Off
© Paramount / Courtesy Everett Collection 7. Clue
"100% one of my favorite movies to watch with the different endings to surprise people."
—u/Tuckerbot1
© Paramount / Courtesy Everett Collection 8. The Godfather
© Paramount / Courtesy Everett Collection 9. The Fifth Element
© Columbia Pictures / Courtesy Everett Collection 10. The Princess Bride
"The casting, the acting, and the dialogue were superb, and NOTHING would be gained by a remake."
—u/comfortablynumb15
"There's a shortage of perfect movies in this world. It would be a shame to ruin this one."
—u/ExNihiloThrowAway
© 20th Century Fox Film Corp. / Courtesy Everett Collection 11. Shrek
"Even 20 years later it holds up. Do not touch it."
—u/wonkagloop
© DreamWorks / Courtesy Everett Collection 12. Fight Club
© 20th Century Fox Film Corp. / Courtesy Everett Collection 13. Schindler's List
"I think a Schindler's List remake would be pretty embarrassing."
—u/Spencelia
© Universal / Courtesy Everett Collection 14. Mystery Men
© Universal / Courtesy Everett Collection 15. Back to the Future
"Back to the Future should stay untouched for its classic charm."
—u/EchoFable24
© MCA / Universal / Courtesy Everett Collection 16. Die Hard
© 20th Century Fox Film Corp. / Courtesy Everett Collection 17. Jaws
© Universal / Courtesy Everett Collection 18. National Lampoon's Animal House
© Universal / Courtesy Everett Collection 19. The Shawshank Redemption
© Columbia Pictures / Courtesy Everett Collection 20. Home Alone
© 20th Century Fox Film Corp. / Courtesy Everett Collection 21. The Goonies
© Warner Bros. / Courtesy Everett Collection 22. The Sandlot
© 20th Century Fox Film Corp. / Courtesy Everett Collection 23. Labyrinth
"That movie was the cause of my sexual awakening. I was the only 8-year-old who put down David Bowie for 'Who's your celebrity crush.' I cried when that man died.
It's also just an amazing movie. Jim Henson has a magical power to make you legitimately forget you are watching puppets.
It can't be redone. Nobody could replace Bowie as Jareth. Anybody else would make it just upsetting and weird instead of magically weird. No man should be able to be that pretty, with better makeup than me yet still be a HUNK. Many had tried."
—u/Beans_0492
© TriStar Pictures / Courtesy Everett Collection 24. The Emperor's New Groove
"A remake of The Emperor’s New Groove would probably be live-action with The Rock as Kronk."
—u/BlizzPenguin
© Buena Vista Pictures / Courtesy Everett Collection 25. The Big Lebowski
© Gramercy Pictures / Courtesy Everett Collection 26. The Lord of the Rings franchise
"LOTR has no remake. LOTR needs no remake."
—u/jonfitt
New Line Cinema / Courtesy Everett Collection Which other movies should never be remade? Share your pick in the comments!
Note: Some responses have been edited for length and/or clarity.