Advertisement

Why you should care about bone health while you're young

Photo: Getty Images
Photo: Getty Images

Which means it’s even more important to strengthen your bones while you’re young — even though it’s the last thing on your mind.

For older men and women, building stronger bones by increasing calcium intake has been a hot topic for some time now.

The questions: Does it work? Is it worth the risks? Or is it too late? Two new studies from the British Medical Journal might do more to sway a divided medical community.

Both BMJ reports cover older populations, specifically men and women over the age of 50. The first study was a meta-analysis of available literature on the effects of increasing calcium, either through diet or supplementation, on bone mineral density.

After surveying 59 eligible pieces of research, they found that the effect was nearly negligible, upping bone density by just one to two percent.

Related: The best foods to fight ageing

The second study specifically focused on calcium’s effect on bone fractures. After reviewing two controlled trials and 50 additional reports from 44 cohort studies, the researchers concluded that dietary calcium intake does not seem to reduce risk of fracture.

They say there is no evidence that “calcium from dietary sources does not prevents fractures,” and evidence that supplements help reduce fractures is “weak and inconsistent.”

According to the study authors, the evidence shows that we should not be championing calcium in older men and women beyond that of a healthy dietary regimen, or suggesting supplements.

Elinor Mody, Director of the Women’s Orthopedic and Joint Disease Center at Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston, says the reports are interesting, but unlikely to settle the debate about whether or not we should be advocating for calcium.

“It brings up the question again, quite nicely, of whether or not we should really be doing this,” she tells Yahoo Health. “It’s a cumbersome pill, calcium isn’t well-absorbed in the body, and there are potential negative side effects like calcium stones and constipation.”

In older populations, bumping calcium intake may be a waste of time.

Related: The amazing effects of caffeine

Does Calcium Really Help Build Bones?

Since our childhood, we’ve been taught that high calcium equals strong bones. But other factors besides calcium intake play into our overall bone health, says Dr Dana Hunnes, senior dietitian at Ronald Reagan UCLA Medical Center.

“Bone health, in general, is internally regulated by the hormones testosterone, estrogen, and parathyroid hormone, and vitamin D, which can act like a hormone,” Hunnes tells Yahoo Health. “When our blood levels of calcium are increased as the body absorbs the mineral from food, that can trigger bone formation — especially when we are younger and have higher levels of the above hormones.”

Since our bone health is mostly guided by an interplay of hormones and other metabolic pathways, it does make sense to Hunnes that calcium supplementation might not affect fractures either way in older populations.

Both Hunnes and Mody do note that, while the authors of the study indicate there is no evidence that increasing calcium through dietary sources seems to help bone health, there are instances where supplementing did seem to be beneficial. “Particularly, a study looking at women in nursing homes who already had very low calcium and vitamin D levels,” says Mody. “In this case, it did seem to help prevent fractures.”

Related: Natural ways to beat back pain

So, it’s still important to check with your doc. Mody says that she generally only recommends supplements to those at high risk for osteoporosis or — for instance, women who are taking a steroid like prednisone. But generally, she doesn’t panic if a patient tells her she’s not taking a calcium supplement.

In fact, vitamin D might be the more important nutrient. Mody says she routinely checks levels of D, since it assists in calcium absorption and many people don’t get enough anyway.

Building Bones at a Young Age

Our bodies need calcium for blood-clotting, signal regulation and muscle contraction, in addition to maintaining strong, healthy bones. “If our blood levels are low, that can trigger our body to break down some bone to get calcium,” says Hunnes. So, obviously, it’s good if you have strong bones with calcium stored away.

While bone fractures probably aren’t on the minds of millennials and the even younger generation, they should be. “While we are young and growing, this is our peak time of bone mineralization,” says Hunnes.

“Until our mid-20s, we are forming, building, and strengthening our bones, so getting high enough levels of calcium and vitamin D is crucial during this time.”

Our bodies can only absorb 500 milligrams of calcium at a given time, says Hunnes, but dietary sources are typically well-tolerated and packed with other nutrients. “This can come from dairy sources, non-dairy sources like soy milk, soy yogurt, almond milk,” she explains. “Other sources are bok choy, broccoli, canned salmon with the bones in, and almonds.”

In terms of diet, what you don’t eat is also important. “It’s smart to avoid excess sugar and sodas at this age,” Hunnes says. “Cola with its high phosphorus content not only replaces ‘calcium-rich’ beverages, but can also remove some of the calcium from our bones in order to neutralize that acid.”

You should also get your vitamin D levels checked regularly to make sure they’re in the normal range, especially if you live in an area with long winters and a lack of sunlight. If your levels are on the low side, Hunnes says a 600-800 IU supplement can go a long way to support long-term bone health.

Related: 9 things you didn't know about coffee

The final ingredient for healthy bones is not dietary — it’s weight-bearing exercise. Just like muscles, bones are living tissue that respond to strengthening exercises. You can build bone mass just like you build muscle mass. “While we are young, the most important things we can do are any type of of weight-bearing activity,” says Hunnes.

Whether that’s a team sport like soccer or hockey, an individual sport like gymnastics or tennis, or simple maintenance exercises like aerobics or weightlifting, anything works that forces your body to work against gravity’s pull.

Just don’t put your bone health off. What you do when you’re young may very well carry you through old age, when supplementation may not help prevent low bone density and debilitating fractures.

Related: Best and worst desk-side snacks