Time to call it: emaciated models are not attractive

April 17, 2013, 10:29 am Marina Go Women's Agenda

Fashion Week models are so thin they're unable to do their job.

Time to call it: emaciated models are not attractive

Getty Images

It was all a bit emperor's new clothes to me. When painfully thin models appeared in many of the shows during Australian Fashion Week last week it seemed apparent that the fashion industry wasn't being honest with its models.

The truth is that the models were too skinny, and unhealthily so. Some made us wince and they didn't do their job. The model's job is to show the designer's clothing in its best light. It was supposed to be about the clothes. And yet the biggest story to come out of the week was the shape and size of the models. Most major news outlets reported on the skinny models. If you surveyed the average female consumer I would put money on the fact that she wouldn't be able to list the major fashion trends from the week.

According to a report on Cleo magazine's website at least one fashion blogger had to photoshop out the angular bones that were detracting from the fashions. In some cases it was difficult to focus on the clothes at all.

When I was a magazine editor in the nineties, the fashion industry was under attack for glamorising the heroin chic look. Pale, angular, skinny models like Kate Moss and heroin addict Jaime King were in demand.

At the time the trend was said to signify a rejection of the healthy, sporty supermodels of the eighties when models like Claudia Schiffer and Cindy Crawford dominated the catwalks of every fashion capital, advertising campaigns and fashion magazine covers.

But fashion is cyclical. What's in one season can be out the next. The emaciated look of the mid-nineties was soon shouted down by a horrified global society and the curvy body was back in fashion courtesy of Brazilian model [ http://au.lifestyle.yahoo.com/marie-claire/video/watch/36ea3ef1-1181-3f48-ba6a-4381f1cd958b/gisele-bundchen-for-hope-lingerie/|Giselle Bundchen].

But fashion is all about the 'next'. And so the fashion pendulum appears to have swung back from supermodel to super skinny. I have read that the skinniest of the models at Fashion Week were those who worked the European shows. The European designers have always preferred relatively thinner models than the Americans. And we seemed willing to accept whatever we could get down here. If skinny models are in demand in Milan and Paris then who is prepared to appear unfashionable or uncool by calling out the obvious?

I was heartened to read Vogue editor Edwina McCann's plea for designers and stylists to choose healthier looking models following the shock of seeing so many ultra-thin frames on the catwalk last week.

Change needs to begin at the top and in the fashion industry the editor of Vogue magazine carries enormous influence. Still. It takes someone whose opinion is key to speak the truth and create change.

When I was the Editor of ELLE magazine in the late nineties a successful, naturally curvy model arrived on our shores looking painfully thin. She was here to promote a particular brand of clothing. When she appeared on the catwalk for the first time, a group of us gasped. There was audible discomfort. We quietly discussed how terrible this model looked. But when her model agent said, "doesn't (model's name) look incredible", fifty heads nodded and a couple even embellished the lie.

The model's body didn't just look thinner, it had changed shape. The word at the time was that the model had removed a rib to achieve her body ideal. I was shocked to hear it at the time. And yet we didn't express the horror we felt. I have thought about this often.

So here and now is the opportunity to right that wrong. Emaciated models with jutting bones are not chic, cool or hot, even if the look is IN for at least some sections of the fashion industry. They do not wear the fashion well. I cannot imagine myself in a designer gown when I am feeling uncomfortable seeing their bones sticking out beneath. I am therefore not inclined to run out and buy the gown. That's how it works.

The fashion media in this country is finally calling out the truth: the emperor was naked and the emaciated look is ugly. When the designers acknowledge the economic impact of their choice of model on their business then maybe they will reject the unhealthy ones. Only then can the industry truly start to change. It is demand that shapes the body type of the modelling industry.

Read Marina Go's last blog post: how to stand out from the pack

Marina Go is the publishing director of Private Media, publisher of Women's Agenda, Crikey, Smart Company, Property Observer, Start Up Smart & Leading Company and a director of Netball Australia. Follow Marina at @MarinasGo and us at @Yahoo7_health

Daily Horoscope

Select your horoscope

Taurus Apr 21 - May 21

It’s all go today for you and, if you’re not super-organised, you’ll get yourself into a total spin. You’re at your most...read more

Edit your profile to update your star sign.

Get Social

Sydney Travel Deals

Change location

5-Day Southern India Tour

  • Full Price

  • Save

  • Time Left

5-Day Southern India Tour