The Genius Trick for Fixing Pie Crust Tears

Few things are more disappointing than pulling a homemade pie crust from the oven and discovering cracks running across its surface. Quelle horreur! While they may seem minor, these tiny tears can wreak havoc on your dessert or pot pie, especially when super wet fillings like custards or fruit compotes are involved. The inevitable seep-through can turn your once-perfect crust into a complete soggy mess. And we all know how much work it is to not only make a gorgeous pie crust but also blind-bake it to perfection. Enter the lifesaver you never knew you needed: pie spackle.

America’s Test Kitchen, a prominent pioneer in cooking and baking brilliance, recently introduced this genius fix, with a cute name to boot ,on their Instagram page. It’s practical, clever and a must-have trick for your holiday pie-baking tool kit this year (because let's be real—not every pie crust is going to behave the way you want it to). Whether you’re making a savory quiche or a family-favorite apple pie, this tip is going to be your go-to solution for keeping your crust flawless.

Related: 15 Spectacular Slab Pies To Feed A Crowd

😋😋 SIGN UP to get delicious recipes, handy kitchen hacks & more in our daily Pop Kitchen newsletter 🍳🍔

View the original article to see embedded media.

Why is Torn Pie Crust a Problem?

A cracked or torn pie crust isn’t just an aesthetic issue. Leaks allow the filling to essentially glue the crust to your pie plate, especially when there are sugary fillings involved, making it nearly impossible to remove clean slices. This can turn a showstopping quiche or pie into a structural disaster. And to top it off, you want a slice of pie with a crisp bottom, not one that's been saturated with misplaced filling or falling apart from excess moisture.

Related: The Genius Pie Trick That Will Please Everyone at the Thanksgiving Table

How to Fix Your Pie Crust with Pie Spackle

Pastry Chef Rochelle Cooper, who creates sweet masterpieces at The Duck & The Peach, La Collina, The Wells, and Meli in Washington, D.C., says that blind baking (also called par-baking) is key when it comes to crispy crust: “General advice is to par-bake your crusts 90% of the way so that it’s flaky and not soggy," she says. "If you don’t have pie weights, you can use foil (spray lightly) and fill it with rice, beans, or flour to weigh it down.”

Sometimes, no matter how careful you are, cracks happen. So after you par-bake, inspect your crust carefully. When you locate a pesky tear, start on that spackle recipe. Mix 4 tablespoons of all-purpose flour, 2 tablespoons of melted butter, and a pinch of sugar together until the texture resembles Play-Doh. Gently press a small amount of this mixture into the cracks or holes of your warm pie crust. Smear the edges to blend it seamlessly with the existing crust. Then, pop the crust back into the oven (this time without the weights or foil) for 5–10 minutes, allowing the spackle to firm up. Though the patched areas might feel slightly different, we guarantee no one will notice once the pie is filled and everyone is happily eating their slices. And the best part? Your crust stays leak-free.

Of course, you can just use extra pie dough to patch up spots, but when scraps are nowhere to be found, this pie spackle is the holiday baking backup plan you didn’t know you needed. And as an Instagram fan says about the ATK tip: “I love the technical terms used here—‘pie spackle.’ Love it!” We couldn’t agree more.

Up Next:

Related: The 110-Year-Old Pecan Pie Recipe That Will Change the Way You Make the Classic Dessert