98 Degrees Is Fully Aware They Were the 'Non-Dancing Boy Band,' Jokes Nick Lachey

Nick Lachey and Jeff Timmons look back at early band decisions that led them to the boy band craze

Tim Mosenfelder/Getty 98 Degrees dancing in 1997

Tim Mosenfelder/Getty

98 Degrees dancing in 1997

98 Degrees didn't sign up to be a boy band, but fate has other plans.

Both Nick Lachey and Jeff Timmons appear in the new Paramount+ documentary Larger Than Life: Reign of the Boybands, discussing how the R&B-centric group ended up mixed into the boy band craze.

"The term boy band was one that we were very hesitant to embrace early on. We never thought of ourselves as a boy band, at least in the conventional sense," Lachey, 51, explains.

"And so we resisted big time, the label of boy band. But then we got very aware that his was a movement that was happening and we were probably lucky to get kind of swept up in it.”

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. 

Tim Roney/Getty Nick Lachey, Justin Jeffre, Jeff Timmons Drew Lachey in early 98 Degrees days in 2000

Tim Roney/Getty

Nick Lachey, Justin Jeffre, Jeff Timmons Drew Lachey in early 98 Degrees days in 2000

Related: How 98 Degrees 'Took a Page Out of Taylor Swift's Playbook' for Their New Album and Tour (Exclusive)

Timmons, 51, agrees, adding, "The plan originally for 98 Degrees was to sell us to the public as a true R&B group."

"We were heavily influenced by the group Boyz II Men," he adds. "But when our label saw the frenzy that was associated with boy bands, they thought, ‘Hey we have our version of a pop group like this.’ "

Though they were initially resistant, after talking it over, Timmons says, "We thought, ‘Maybe it’s not a bad idea.’ "

Source: Nick Lachey/Instagram 98 Degrees
Source: Nick Lachey/Instagram 98 Degrees

Related: AJ McLean Recalls 'Really Dark Time' with Backstreet Boys, Realizing 'Something's Not Right' When He Drank on Stage

Laughing, Timmons notes, "At the time, boy bands were all about dancing and Lord knows, we were not all about dancing.”

Lachey agrees that the choreography piece was tough for them.

“We always joked that we were the non-dancing boy band. We never auditioned, we never went through dance class. We put ourselves together, we moved to California, we sang for people and we got discovered. And from there, we kind of got swept up into a whole other thing.”

Hear more about 98 Degrees' rise to boy band fame, alongside the stories of other boy bands, in Larger Than Life: Reign of the Boybands, now streaming on Paramount+.