HEART WEEK: Exercise and Heart Problems

May 4, 2012, 12:03 pm Dr Andre La Gerche firstoffthebike.com

Why do some endurance athletes develop serious heart rhythm problems? Heart Specialist, Dr Andre La Gerche, has spent the past 5 years trying to understand this issue, researching the story of former world champion triathlete, Emma Carney, who had a near-fatal heart problem. But what does this mean for your everyday athlete?

Does Exercise Cause Heart Problems?
Triathlon

Let’s provide some context with some simple and irrefutable facts:

- Moderate exercise has undeniable health benefits. It is associated with a longer life, a lower risk of heart attack, less diabetes, lower rates of some cancers, less depression etc etc. Guidelines recommend 150 minutes of moderate exercise (such as jogging) per week.

- The risk of dying from a heart rhythm problem in healthy young adults is somewhere around 4 per million, about 10 times less likely than being killed in a car accident.

- The risk of dying from a heart attack (caused by a blockage of an artery to the heart) is much higher than the risk of dying from a heart rhythm. Exercise is a very good way of preventing a heart attack because it improves cholesterol, blood pressure etc.

You can essentially summarise all discussion of sudden death in young athletes under the banner VERY RARE.

Emma Carney’s Story
Emma Carney is an Australian former professional triathlete and two time World Triathlon Champion. She is one of the few triathletes in the world to have won two ITU world titles.

Getty Images

Carney was forced to retire from professional triathlon in 2004 after suffering a cardiac arrest in Canada. She was later diagnosed with ventricular tachycardia, a life-threatening condition that causes the heart to beat too fast and out of control, usually during high-intensity anaerobic exercise. The doctors found it difficult to diagnose her condition, partly because Carney's resting heart rate when asleep was only 21 bpm. In October 2004 surgeons implanted an Implantable Cardioverter Defibrillator (ICD) in the right ventricle of her heart. (Source: Wikipedia)

Are You at Risk?

With Emma’s story in mind, what causes an elite athlete to develop life threatening heart rhythm problems? Do all athletes put themselves at a greater risk of life threatening heart arrhythmias?

At present, no one has any answers to this second question, however, if there is an excess risk in athletes, it is very, very small.

Dr Andre La Gerche delves deeper into both these issues at First Off The Bike, explaining the source of heart problems and the associated risks of exercise.

The Bottom Line Is...

Train sensibly. Consider your heart as part of the total package. It can become fatigued and overtrained just as your other muscles can. I would argue that if you train sensibly you will avoid poor performances and you will further reduce an already very small risk of heart rhythm problems.

Related Links: Top 5 foods for a healthy heart

Dr Andre La Gerche MBBS, FRACP, PhD Cardiologist (St Vincent’s Hospital Melbourne) and currently continuing research in Sports Cardiology at the University Hospital of Leuven, Belgium.

First Off The Bike is Australia's first stop for triathlon news, and gives triathletes the inside edge with news, interviews, comment and race reports from Australia and overseas. For updates on the triathlon industry, go to Firstoffthebike.com

Show:
Newest First
Oldest First
Top Rated
Most Replies

7 Comments

  1. paul p02:29pm Sunday 29th May 2011 ESTReport Abuse

    if one thrashs their body beyond it ability , what do you think is gunna happen , derrr !

    Reply
  2. Stevey02:28pm Sunday 29th May 2011 ESTReport Abuse

    I admire Triatheletes , such a difficult sport . I do agree that on some level you have to be obessive , Id love to complete one personally however , I think the feeling crossing that finish line would be nothing short of incredible . Dont use this article as an excuse to be big FATTIE !EXERCISE .

    Reply
  3. Sydney02:24pm Sunday 29th May 2011 ESTReport Abuse

    Where's my Sun ?!

    Reply
  4. DIANA12:32pm Sunday 29th May 2011 ESTReport Abuse

    hi ,my name is diana sinko, i go to gym every day seven days a week. i do every thing from weight to skipping and running on threadmill. i do work out two hours to hour and a half a day. could you please tell me if i am risk of having heart attack of what i do? thanks diana

    1 Reply
  5. Blewvane12:31pm Sunday 29th May 2011 ESTReport Abuse

    Now excercise is bad for us??? hahahahaha

    Reply