Soapbox

Court rules 10 year old to see her dying father

Sep 01 08:12am

The Family Court in Sydney has ruled a 10-year-old girl must see he dying father within 28 days. The girl has said publicly that she wants her father - who she hasn't seen since 2003 - to die. He is terminally ill with cancer.

In the case, the judge did comment on the mother, saying she has "an intense hatred" of the father.

An expert told the court that if the father dies without the child being able to say goodbye, the child will come to regret this later in life.

Psychologist Jo Lamble says this is a dangerous situation. The court wants reconciliation, but a meeting could cause more problems for the girl. Can a 10-year-old live with bad decisions she makes at this age? Jo says there could be an element of brainwashing by the mother, who has started a new family, but this is a common problem.

If the father wants reconciliation, Jo says he needs to make a huge effort. He should be writing letters so in the future, if the girl has regrets, she will still have those memories of him.


What do you think? Should the girl be forced to see her father?

 

18 Comments Report Abuse
11. dottii1 - Sep 02 06:51pm
Parental alienation can also occur because of violence and abuse towards the child. This ten child may have good reason to hate her father. We dont know. In today's court climate, contact is everything and 'experts' never seem to vary on enforcing this. Dont just blame the mother.
12. dottii1 - Sep 02 06:57pm
Those who write of past situations,I suggest you read recent judgments. All give contact.
I know of several bad dv cases where dad got the kids because mum was so petrified of him, 'experts' decided that she could 'not facilitate the realtionship'. It has changed and not always for the better.
13. thenewvoice8 - Sep 03 09:25am
Of course she should see her dad before he dies, not only will she regret it later on life she may be too young to appreciate the gravity of the situation and, rightly or wrongly, her mothers influence on her thoughts.

another sunrise neurosis article -when their are so many real issues out there
14. brockleydon - Sep 06 11:04am
She should be forced to see her father. If she doesn't, and her father dies, she would regret it for the rest of her life.
15. jo_jom45 - Sep 16 05:43am
Its about time the courts started listening to what the AFFECTED CHILDREN want and not to spiteful unreasonable parents. I'm a parent of 4 teenagers and have to put up with bad moods and agro as they don't want contact but the court says different. It should be up to the child.
16. jo_jom45 - Sep 16 05:43am
Its about time the courts started listening to what the AFFECTED CHILDREN want and not to spiteful unreasonable parents. I'm a parent of 4 teenagers and have to put up with bad moods and agro as they don't want contact but the court says different. It should be up to the child.
17. calmlife67 - Sep 21 11:18am
I think she should see her father. I grew up without mine because of my mothers selfishness and then after 33 years of looking I found he had died 4 years prior to me finding him and his family.I had a hatred for my ex husband but I never once let it get in the way of his relationship with our Son.
18. calmlife67 - Sep 21 11:23am
It pains me so much when Parents use their children to get back at the other parent. Now matter your feelings for your ex your child deserves to be able to see them or it will scar for life. If abuse is a factor used supervised visits. Its not your right to take this from a child.
Leave your comments You must sign in to leave a comment

latest videos

Eskimo Joe perform their hit single "Don't Let Me Down" live from Brekky Central.

Video

today's thought

Destiny decides who you meet in your life, but it's our heart that decides who stays in our life. - Gale, TAS

Do you have a thought for Mel?

Special Offer

All the latest deals from Jetstar

Latest offers

soapbox

Kurt Fearnley: I was relief teaching in Blayney when I met Kurt as a young school boy. The first thing that struck me was his smile and contagious positive outlook at all times. I see nothing has changed with this outstanding Australian. Although I never saw him again, it is a testament to the power of his personality that I have not forgotten him more than 15 years later.

Email Sunrise