Health

On the couch with clinical psychologist Jo Lamble - Mother-in-law advice

Sep 04 11:50am

If you have the mother-in-law from hell, follow these strategies to help maintain your sanity, says New idea's Clinical Psychologist Jo Lamble.

Q. I know it sounds like a cliche, but my mother-in-law is driving me crazy. She's a lovely woman who means well, but she has an opinion on everything we do. Whatever I do with our one-year-old son is wrong. Whatever I do around the house is wrong. How I treat my husband is wrong. How can I tell her to butt out without destroying our relationship forever?
Gayle, Campbelltown, NSW.

A. Wow, I really hope your mother-in-law settles down over time when she sees the good job you're doing with her grandchild. Meanwhile, here are a few things you should and should not do.

It's your issue
Firstly, don't expect your husband to talk to his mum about the issue. A lot of women think their partners should stand up to their mothers and defend their wife. Obviously, if your mother-in-law were abusing you, I'd expect your husband to speak up. But if she's just full of opinions, then I wouldn't jeopardise your husband's relationship with his mum by asking him to fight your battles.

Keep a nag tally
Instead of dwelling on her criticism, protect your ego and reduce your frustration by keeping a diary. Every time you speak to her, make a mark on that day's date if she tells you you're doing something wrong. Tally up the marks after a call or visit to see how many she can squeeze into one conversation. By tallying her negative comments, you'll be standing back naturally and observing her. Without knowing it, you'll stop taking her comments personally because you'll be hoping she beats her old record. Who knows, you might even enjoy the project.

Ask for her advice
Another strategy is to ask her opinion before she gives it. As soon as she rings, ask her what you should feed your son or how you should handle a situation that happened at the park, then tell her how much you appreciate her advice. This way you have some control over the situation. You'll also get lots of brownie points, which should decrease her general negativity towards you.

Why she does it
Think about your mother-in-law's behaviour. What is it about her personality and her situation that makes her so opinionated and critical? Is she unhappy, lonely or depressed? Does she miss having young children herself? Was her mother highly critical? Imagining what life is like for your mother-in-law, given her personality and her situation, is called having empathy.
Developing empathy for your mother-in-law will help you from taking her comments so personally because you'll realise her behaviour says more about her than it does about you. I'm sure your husband will also appreciate your efforts to deal with his difficult mother, which should make him more understanding of how hard it's been for you.

40 Comments Report Abuse
1. stormsjill - Sep 06 10:38am
I think her problem is she's an old bat who can't keep her mouth shut... my solutions would be:
1. Move far away
2. Get her to move far away
3. Tell everyone she's moving far away and bury her in the back yard ;)
2. luvviej - Sep 06 11:15am
icouldnt b so calm id blow up
3. catherine_magraith - Sep 06 11:28am
i totally disagree with the comments. It's time for him to cut the apron strings and decide who he's rather live him. It's vital that he stands up for you early on, or else the nagging will NEVER stop!
4. susanmlee2007 - Sep 06 11:56am
I agree with Catherine - if a man is unwilling or unable to stand up to his mother then is he really ready to be a husband and father? If he'd rather be Mummy's little soldier then I'm sure she'd be only too happy for him to move back in with her. HE needs to be the one to explain to his mother that he's all grown up now, he appreciates everything she's done for him and he'd like for her to be his friend now rather than his Mummy. If she's unwilling to accept this new role in his life then he ha
5. magnolia2005poem - Sep 06 12:03pm
And I totally disagree with the comments; I paid very expensive price to be nice and forgiving to my ex-mother in low: depression and divorce.....My advices:
1. run away from her and don't leave your new address and phone number to her;
2. allow your husband to visit her twice a year only;
3. make that agreement with him before you married him!
all the best.....
6. hhanbury7 - Sep 06 12:08pm
I think the advice given Jo is excellent. I used to ahve the mother in law from hell and decided to fight fire with fire. While it may seem fun at first and the need to win outweighs anything else, eventually it eats away at you, your partner and the whole family. The family is supposed to be a strong unity and anything you can do to keep it that wau is best. My current mother in law is a bit of a nagger as well and often adds negative comments in. I didn't want to be like my last relationship a
7. hhanbury7 - Sep 06 12:09pm
Q
8. magnolia2005poem - Sep 06 12:11pm
sorry, I was so furious with psychologist advices that instead of "agree" I wrote in the comments No.5 "disagree".......
HUSBAND MUST EXPLAIN TO HIS MOTHER THAT HE IS IN THE FIRST PLACE:
1. HUSBAND
2. FATHER
3. INDEPENDENT MAN
4. than her son...........
9. kyliep22 - Sep 06 12:13pm
I think you should just be honest. Tell her that you are the mother & that you know what is best for your child and if you wanted her opinion you would ask for it. If you dont want to destroy your relationship with her you just need to tell her upfront that her comments are making you feel like you arent a good enough mother & wife & ask how she would feel or how she felt if her mother inlaw critisized her all the time. She should get the message & if not just keep pushing the issue until she do
10. magnolia2005poem - Sep 06 12:14pm
sorry, I was so furious with psychologist advices that instead of "agree" I wrote in the comments No.5 "disagree".......
HUSBAND MUST EXPLAIN TO HIS MOTHER THAT HE IS IN THE FIRST PLACE:
1. HUSBAND
2. FATHER
Leave your comments You must sign in to leave a comment

Poll

Join Us

Become a member and receive our email newsletters.

Dating and Cars

Find your match

Singles in Australia

Yahoo!7 Dating
Carsales

Search new & used cars