Life + Style

David Koch - Rent vs Buy

Jul 17 12:21pm

The Aussie dream of owning property is fast becoming a thing of the past.

Q: With housing prices starting to move up as well as interest rates set to rise again, it's now almost impossible for us to buy a house. Saving for a deposit is getting beyond our reach. How can we at least get to first base and manage to build up enough savings for a deposit?
Susan, Northcote, V.

A: Susan, please read on for my financial argument on why
it's a good idea to continue renting rather than buy your own home.

Rent vs own
Even though some property markets will go through boom periods, over the long term, residential property hasn't performed as well as shares in our major companies. Then there are the high costs of purchasing property, such as stamp duty, legal costs and land tax. While owner-occupied property is capital gains tax free, the interest payments aren't tax deductible as they are on investment property.


Forced savings

For a lot of Australians, owning a house with a mortgage becomes a forced-savings program. We meet our repayments and work hard to pay it off early, thus increasing our home's equity and building an investment. It's not the best way to build an investment asset, but we seem happier to do this than build an investment portfolio elsewhere.

Building wealth
A university study a few of years ago concluded that, given the high costs involved in buying residential investment property, it's only after 17 years of continuous ownership that a home buyer financially ends up in front of a person who rents!

So the better option is to continue to rent, and to invest the difference between your rent and a mortgage on an equivalent property elsewhere - most renters spend the difference. The first step is to work out that difference. The second is to arrange for that amount to be automatically transferred from your bank account to a high-interest account.

When the balance in the account is big enough, transfer it to a growth-oriented investment such as a managed fund or shares. You'll need to sit down with a financial planner and work out where the money will go. They will advise on the fund managers or stocks to follow and make sure the portfolio is diversified enough to provide good, consistent returns. Once you've built up a portfolio, you can decide to keep renting and investing the difference, or use the money to buy a home.


The final decision
A lot of your decision will depend on your renting experience. If you're in a nice place with a good landlord, then there's a sense of security. But if you've had narky landlords or have had to move a lot, then buying your own house will seem like a godsend.


Buying your own home is more
of a lifestyle and peace-of-mind decision than a financial one. It's also good for those who find it hard to invest because they can achieve that by building up their equity.

Financial housekeeping
Apart from investing the difference between your rent and anticipated mortgage, you'll reach your deposit level a lot quicker if you overhaul.


the way you manage your finances as a whole.

  • Do a budget and work out ways to cut down incidental expenses so you can save more. Taking your own lunch to work can save $5 to $10 a day, which is $50 a week or a little more than $2500 a year.
  • Be savvy with your tax. Split your income by putting surplus money into an interest-bearing account in joint names or the name of a non-working spouse.
  • Make sure you have adequate term-life cover and income protection so that your dependants won't suffer in the event that the unthinkable happens.
More from David Koch
98 Comments Report Abuse
1. jazz_no1chick - Jul 19 08:27am
this is all great in theory, however, "building you income" these days if your renting is only possible if you have a higher than average income or have double average and higher income. this theory only works in certain areas. a lot of ppl who rent would find the amount they pay in rent ea week is almost the same as a mortgage repayment which is why you buy instead its pricey to start with but the money isnt dead money. also those who rent esp if u have a family wont have much left over to cons
2. venturefocus - Jul 19 08:49am
We also have the situation developing where there are a shortage
of rental properties, resulting in a rent sqeeze.
As a result we are now seeing "rent auctions" where people have to bid on the amount of rent they will pay for a rental property.
The Real Estate agents must be having wet dreams over that one!
Are we heading down the European road where nearly everyone rents because it's all too expensive?
Must we finally give up "the Australian dream" ?
3. philip_mackertich - Jul 19 09:03am
Sorry Koche i disagree with nearly everything you have said. Your telling people "A university study a few of years ago concluded that, given the high costs involved in buying residential investment property, it's only after 17 years of continuous ownership that a home buyer financially ends up in front of a person who rents!"

What about studies that every 10 years property in Sydney nearly doubles? What about the population boom that is going to see the price of houses increase? The best ti
4. philip_mackertich - Jul 19 09:04am
Sorry Koche i disagree with nearly everything you have said. Your telling people "A university study a few of years ago concluded that, given the high costs involved in buying residential investment property, it's only after 17 years of continuous ownership that a home buyer financially ends up in front of a person who rents!"

What about studies that every 10 years property in Sydney nearly doubles? What about the population boom that is going to see the price of houses increase? The best ti
5. jazz_no1chick - Jul 19 09:09am
out it this way my partner and i are both high earners. we live in cqld however we rent our house is cheap for the area most houses are more like 350 ^ we only pay 270 but after bills we dont have much left not for these types of savings. and it would be worse in major cities. ppl here pay 700 for rent. we are only fortunate enough that we have saved and been wise to have the deposit for a house. the other thing tho is the it is now cheaper here to build than buy. there are no rentals so its sky
6. jazz_no1chick - Jul 19 09:12am
these tips are all very well and good for people who have high stable incomes, dont have major or high expenses such as families and exisiting loans. and this would only really work for the buiness men or those earning over 70-100,000.00 per year. who have the money to save and invest. any way you look at it rent money is dead money, even if it does take a while to get in front at least your money is doing something, you have equity etc rent ppls dont have anything at all after 17 years jsut les
7. jazz_no1chick - Jul 19 09:13am
* no rentals so rent is shy high so ppl must buy so houses are sky high. its no win.
8. jazz_no1chick - Jul 19 09:17am
*less money they have no equity, and not investment status. if you buy an investment house and rent it out chances are that thier rental might cover your rent and you still have the mortgage to consider. i dont agree that houses will never lose some houses here are old and going for 400 i wouldnt buy them cos you wont sell than at the same price. if your going to buy u have to be smart and look to the future. what can u sell in 10 or 15 years.
9. brianhammill - Jul 19 10:28am
renting all sounds wonderful until you get to retirement age cos at that point if you havent been real real careful with your money then you are in deep poo.
10. jazz_no1chick - Jul 19 10:36am
Not to mention that you dont own anything so you have nothing to pass down to your children and thier children. also should the need arise you have nothing stable to lean on such as your equity etc. if you buy in the right area at a good cost for the house and area you wont ever loose plus u have that added security which to some is worth more at the end of the day than anything else.
Leave your comments You must sign in to leave a comment

Poll

on sale now

New issue on sale now!

More from this week's issue


Our new ad

Join Us

Become a member and receive our email newsletters.

Cars and Jobs

FPV v HSV GTS

Best local sports sedans

Yahoo!7 Cars
Foot in the door

Graduate jobs


Connect With Others on Yahoo!7 Groups

Mums n Bubs Come and have a chat, swap advice about babies from newborn to 5 years.

Shoe Heaven Enter my world of mules, wedges, slides, platforms, sandals or pumps!

Weekend Gardener This is a club for the green thumb in all of us.