Our Experts

Cholesterol & Heart Disease
Your Healthy Heart

How Hard Should You Exercise?

Sep 06 09:32am

When it comes to exercising, the trick is to work out hard enough to produce heart-healthy benefits and yet not so fiercely that you do yourself harm. Luckily, there are several easy ways to determine whether your level of activity is helping or harming you:

  • The talk test. You have exceeded the moderate-intensity level if you are breathing so hard that you cannot carry on a normal conversation.

  • The "8 to 20" scale. Consider the intensity of exercise on a scale from 8 to 20, where 8 is barely moving and 20 is the most extreme exercise you can imagine. On this scale, moderate-intensity exercise would be rated as about a 12.

  • Heart rate. During moderate-intensity exercise, your heart rate should remain between 50 percent and 70 percent of your maximum heart rate. You can estimate the range of your maximum heart rate by subtracting your age from 220 and then multiplying that figure first by 0.5 (that is, by 50 percent) and then by 0.7 (70 percent). Thus, a 50-year-old man, to assure he's getting moderate exercise, would aim for a heart rate between 85 (220 - 50 = 170 x 0.5 = 85) and 119 (220 - 50 = 170 x 0.7 = 119) beats per minute.

If you prefer lifting weights, my colleague Dr. Kerry Stewart, an exercise physiologist at Johns Hopkins, recommends this way to determine how much weight to use for resistance training: Find a weight you can lift comfortably for about 12 to 15 repetitions. That amount of weight will represent about 30 percent to 40 percent of your maximum lifting ability, he says. (Another tip: Breath-holding inevitably accompanies weightlifting, but try to avoid holding your breath for extended periods.)

90 Comments Report Abuse
1. scelanges - Feb 10 02:39am
My name is Sylvia and I work for a patient education agency that creates patient educational materials.

We are currently working on a project that is looking to address the challenges and barriers to medication adherence in patients.

We are looking to interview patients that have one or more of the following:
High Blood Pressure
Heart Failure
a previous heart attack
We are also looking for patients that are taking a beta-blocker.

The interview is 60 minutes and we will pay $50.00 for your time.

If you are intersted, please call me at 908-654-4440

Thanks
Sylvia
2. catnap321 - Feb 10 11:31am
By the end of my run, my heart rate is up to 80-85% of my max. If I trained at 50-70%, I'd never get very far. I do push myself to run fast at the end of the run & my heart rate recovery is quite fast. Could the formula or the ranges not be one-size-fits-all??
3. holly1959booth - Feb 10 04:21pm
Catnap321, it sounds like you are right on track. If your HR recovers quickly that says your in good CV shape. That formula has been around for well over 25 years, it is not very accurate. In my opinion, if you train at 50-70% of your max, you would have to be just starting out to and have led a very non-active life in order for it to do much good. Most people believe that your aerobic zone begins at about 65% -85% of your max. It all depends on lots of things, but I believe you have to really test things for yourself and not believe charts or formula's that are not specific. Just my two cents, for what it is worth. ;)
4. catnap321 - Feb 11 06:14am
#3 holly: Thanks for your comment. I thought 50-70% sounded low.
5. rtaverde - Feb 27 07:10am
I just recently got a heart rate monitor and have been running for years. On my easy runs, my heart rate is around 157 (85%) but I don't feel winded at all. I tried getting it lower but I am almost walking. I figure my heart rate is just fast. Anyone know what else it could be?
6. rtaverde - Feb 27 07:10am
I just recently got a heart rate monitor and have been running for years. On my easy runs, my heart rate is around 157 (85%) but I don't feel winded at all. I tried getting it lower but I am almost walking. I figure my heart rate is just fast. Anyone know what else it could be?
7. prettybecky1983 - Mar 14 09:49am
THATS DEFINATELY GOOD INFO TO KNOW AND EASY TO CALCULATE FOR SOMEONE JUST STARTING OUT LIKE MYSELF.. THANKS!
8. hannelore35 - Sep 06 11:36pm
I understand your comment on the heart=rate,now I try to find a way to do some workout,since I have RA and OA.Iam doing the bike one mile a day and exercise for 10 minutes 2 times a day.I can not walk very far.Any help?
9. funchck98 - Sep 10 12:41am
hahaaa, i dont like this very much, and i also have ocd because i bite my nails all the time, and of course there is no cure. i bet you there isnt! you just have to learn how to stop on you own!? duhhhhh. bye!
10. funchck98 - Sep 10 12:42am
nobody cares
Leave your comments You must sign in to leave a comment
Yahoo!7 Answers

Health Questions with Yahoo!7 Answers